Showing posts with label MOOCs. Show all posts
Showing posts with label MOOCs. Show all posts

Sunday, 24 November 2013

MOOCs and the Liberal Arts College

         MOOCs and the Liberal Arts College


Claudia W. Scholz

Coordinator of Research Programs
Office of Academic Affairs
Trinity University
San Antonio, TX 78212 USA
claudia.scholz@trinity.edu

Abstract

In this paper, the author examines lessons from massive open online courses (MOOCs) for small liberal arts colleges (LACs) in the United States. While some consider MOOCs a threat to LACs, they can also be seen as a provocation to spur small institutions to improve their offerings and assert their place in the higher education landscape. The paper examines how LACs might draw on the best tools, approaches, and structures emerging from the MOOC revolution in order to help students build lifelong learning habits.

Keywords: massive open online course (MOOC), liberal arts college (LAC), institutional strategy, lifelong learning

Introduction

At first blush, the massive open online courses (MOOCs) offered by Coursera, edX, and Udacity contrast markedly with the learning environment of liberal arts colleges (LACs). Where MOOCs are massive, LACs are defined by small classes. Where MOOCs are open, LACs cultivate selectivity. Where MOOCs operate in the "high-tech" realm of online content delivery and "big data," LACs emphasize residential interactions and "high-touch" relationships. For these reasons and others, some higher education leaders have discounted the educational value of MOOCs and doubt their potential to disrupt the liberal arts tradition (Edmundson, 2012; Falk, 2012).

Nevertheless, MOOCs are of great interest and concern to those of us committed to the LAC experience. Free college-level courses raise economic and existential concerns for small colleges with high tuition rates (Judson, 2013). On the flip side, careful employment of MOOCs could provide alternative income streams, enrollment options, and credentialing frameworks to better position small colleges in a challenging and highly competitive higher education market. Certain approaches and technologies popularized by MOOCs may be adapted to support instruction at LACs, for example, offering remediation outside of class-time to students who need support, scaffolding individual problem-solving tasks (An, 2010), or supplementing the curriculum with more advanced or rare opportunities.

More importantly, MOOCs provoke us, as faculty, to examine our own teaching practice. We defend the unique value of face-to-face interactions with our students while allowing traditional pedagogies and authoritarian classroom roles to dominate our practice. We cling to traditional texts and ways of producing them, even as our students produce videos and curate content online (Lukes, 2012). Insofar as MOOCs provoke LAC faculty to think more deeply about learning, exploring new approaches, and reviving sometimes staid teaching techniques, they present an exciting opportunity (Davidson, 2012b).

This position paper outlines some of the ways in which LACs can adapt and flourish in the face of MOOCs, adopting the best of educational technologies while asserting the continuing value of the liberal arts college tradition.

MOOCs as a Threat

In 50 years, if not much sooner, half of the roughly 4,500 colleges and universities now operating in the United States will have ceased to exist. The technology driving this change is already at work, and nothing can stop it.(Harden, 2013, p. 55)

"Thirty years from now the big university campuses will be relics. Universities won't survive. It's as large a change as when we first got the printed book ... Higher education is in deep crisis."
– Peter Drucker (quoted in Lenzner & Johnson, 1997, p. 126)

MOOCs have been portrayed as a disruption (Horn & Christensen, 2013), a "tsunami" (Brooks, 2012), a threat to faculty autonomy and intellectual property (Schmidt, 2013), a Trojan horse disguising for-profit motives (Cost et al., 2013), and a "techno-utopian fantasy of automating higher education and driving its price to zero" (Mazel, 2012, para. 2). The New York Times and The Chronicle of Higher Education termed 2012 the "year of the MOOC" (Pappano, 2012; Watters, 2012b), and predictions abounded that institutions of higher education would soon face the same fate as travel agents and record labels, made obsolete by cheap or free online alternatives (Shirky, 2012).

Nevertheless, history tells us that traditional institutions of higher education will likely continue to coexist with MOOCs (Siemens & Matheos, 2010). As Peter Drucker's comment above illustrates, predictions about the Internet destroying higher education are nearly as old as the World Wide Web itself. Large, elite institutions may be shielded, at least in the short term, by their reputations and endowments from the impact of MOOC mania. Indeed, some of these institutions – for example, Stanford University, Harvard University, and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) – are centers for the production of MOOCs, being the birthplaces of the "Big-Three" MOOC platforms: Coursera, edX, and Udacity. Local and highly specialized institutions, including many community colleges, will likely also weather the storm because of their niche markets and lower costs (Cusumano, 2013). The institutions deemed most vulnerable in this revolution are those in the middle, where costs are high but the buffers of reputation and endowments are lower. LACs are in the eye of the storm.

This storm has been brewing for quite some time. It is part of a changing dynamic within all information industries that reduces the power and influence, indeed the necessity, of mediating institutions (Siemens & Matheos, 2010). It is also shaped by a cultural shift in the meaning and purpose of education. While LACs espouse a holistic approach to education, emphasizing citizenship and critical thinking over specific career skills, the MOOC revolution is part of a larger trend to view education as a service. This consumer-oriented view emphasizes the connections between higher education and future employment or income (Kiley, 2012).

The residential college experience, while always limited in practice, has traditionally occupied a dominant place in the cultural imagination. The vision of higher education as a "bundled" product provided by one's "alma mater" is giving way to the idea that education can be cobbled together with online courses (massive or less so), internships, and other learning experiences (Kamenetz, 2010). MOOC providers like Coursera and Udacity emphasize the link between education and employment by offering placement services, promising to bring successful students to the attention of Google and other big-name companies. These cultural and economic changes, coupled with rising tuition, started to take their toll on LACs long before the MOOC "tsunami." Out of 212 LACs identified in 1990, only 130 can still be classified as such today. Most of the remainder changed their institutional missions to orient themselves more to the professions while some merged with other institutions and a few closed their doors (Baker, Baldwin, & Makker, 2012; Jaschik, 2012).

Institutions that will weather this latest storm are the ones that are able to convince students, parents, and donors that their model of education is not only viable, but superior to free or cheap alternatives. Already, institutions are rallying their defenses, pointing to the value of a face-to-face education. Statistics professor Susan Holmes in an oft-quoted Public Broadcasting Service interview, opines, "I don't think that you can give a Stanford education online, in the same way as I don't think that Facebook gives you a social life" (Michels, 2013, para. 39). This has been the response of many defenders of traditional educational models. Critics of MOOCs are also quick to point to a number of high-profile failures, including student complaints about a lack of faculty responsiveness (Watters, 2012a), and technological limitations (Kolowich, 2013b) that highlight the growing pains of the Big-Three MOOC platforms. While such criticisms are important, the challenge of MOOCs is not just in their technology and structure, but in the way they are changing expectations about the cost and delivery of education.

MOOCs as Tools for Blended Learning

"Does it really make sense to have thousands of community-college instructors developing the same courses?"
– Coursera co-founder Daphne Koller (quoted in Kamenetz, 2012, "Tech Ed," para. 28)

Professors may well assign MOOCs as homework, for example, and then build on the information in them through more in-depth and interactive discussions in the classroom. This has been referred to as "flipping the paradigm," so that the classroom is used for interaction, not passive absorption of the professor's insights. (Skorton & Altschuler, 2013)

A number of faculty and administrators from elite LACs have taken an "if you can't beat 'em, join 'em" approach to MOOCs. Wellesley College became a partner in edX in December of 2012 and Wesleyan University faculty are offering courses through Coursera in 2013 (Tilsley, 2012). Even LACs not interested in producing MOOCs themselves are looking for ways to employ MOOCs in their own courses or degree programs. Indeed, MOOCs fit into the blended learning approach (Daly, 2013) currently espoused by many LACs. The Associated Colleges of the South has instituted a grant program to incentivize blended learning. Faculty at Wesleyan and Bryn Mawr College have integrated modules from the Open Learning Initiative (OLI) at Carnegie Mellon University into courses on statistics and chemistry (Kolowich, 2012c).

Blended approaches purport to combine the best of online and face-to-face teaching and learning. Technology offers students access to multimedia materials and asynchronous, self-scheduled learning, removing content delivery from the face-to-face classroom to make room for problem solving, knowledge-application, and hands-on activities. The insertion of MOOCs into this framework can be problematic, however. Aligning a face-to-face course with a MOOC is not the same as adopting a textbook or putting together a course packet. I summarize some of the contrasts in Table 1.

Table 1. Textbooks and MOOCs – comparing elements

Supplementary multimedia content and quiz banks often available at extra costQuizzes and assignments usually embedded in video content Available during period designated by the provider, with the exception of some self-paced Udacity courses (Marques & McGuire, 2013)

Intended for use in a course settingTerms of Service may limit the free use of the materials for credit-bearing courses (Kolowich, 2012b)

Responsibility of purchase lies with the studentResponsibility for any required fees lies with the institutionEasy for instructor to skip a chapter, assign alternate or supplementary readingsImpossible to replace or customize content within the MOOC itselfGenerally copyedited and aided by graphic designer, fact checkers, and editorsVideo production value leaves a lot to be desired (Scholz, 2012)

Since MOOCs are generally based on existing face-to-face courses, they follow the rhythm of their home campus in terms of semester length, lecture frequency, and workload. While pieces of MOOCs, such as video lectures, simulations, assignments, quizzes, and exams may be of use in a face-to-face class, the online course as a whole may be too inflexible to allow such materials to be easily blended with a face-to-face class on a different campus. MOOCs are structured as hubs around which individual learners gather, not as open educational resources or even learning management systems that can be adapted to other purposes, though recent agreements between Coursera and 10 state university systems may signal a change, with promise that "professors teaching at these schools will have the opportunity to develop online courses through Coursera, as well as adapt existing Coursera courses for their own classrooms" (Coursera, 2013, para. 3).

MOOC as a Provocation

Content is easily duplicated and has no value. What is valuable, however, is that which can't be duplicated without additional input costs: personal feedback and assessment, contextualized and personalized navigation through complex topics, encouragement, questioning by a faculty member to promote deeper thinking, and a context and infrastructure of learning. Basically: human input costs make education valuable. (Siemens, 2011, para. 12)

By democratizing Ivy League-level lectures, Coursera and its cohorts will force the nation's colleges to prove their value in other ways. (Oremus, 2012, para. 14)

Arguably the most important role MOOCs can currently play for LACs is as a foil against which to demonstrate our value. Insofar as MOOCs push educators to reflect on the nature of learning, they are a welcome challenge (Davidson, 2012b). Already, conversations about MOOCs have prompted the development of a Bill of Rights and Principles for Learning in the Digital Age (Brown et al., 2013; Davidson, 2013; Kolowich, 2013a), which will certainly provide fodder for thinking about learning, both online and offline, for some time.

The flurry of attention paid to the Big-Three MOOC platforms in the last year has yielded fruitful comparisons to early experiments in MOOCs led by George Siemens and Stephen Downes in Canada, including the 2008 inaugural course titled Connectivism and Connective Knowledge (CCK08). A U.S. example (though these courses transcend national boundaries) is Digital Storytelling (DS106), which has been coordinated by Jim Groom at the University of Mary Washington since 2010. These courses, now termed connectivist or "cMOOCs" (Siemens, 2012) to contrast them with Big-Three "xMOOCs," use social media and Rich Site Summary to distribute course materials and manage virtual discussions (Downes, 2011). While xMOOCs center the video lecturer as the focus of the course and the course platform as its hub, the objective of cMOOCs is for students to create shared knowledge and take charge of their own learning using a blog or social media account to communicate with their peers. Indeed, the connectivist model of cMOOCs provides options for incorporating online technologies into the classroom that may be more suited to the missions and habits of LACs (King & Nanfito, 2012).

The following subsections will explore in greater detail how the challenge of MOOCs might bring about new opportunities for LACs to improve student learning and affirm the value of the education we provide.

What Could "Massive" Mean for LACs?

MOOCs offered by the Big-Three platforms have averaged 50,000 enrollees, with a high of 180,000 (see, for example, How to Reason and Argue, offered byDuke University). While completion rates typically range from far below 10% to a high of 19%, the smallest number of students reportedly completing a MOOC on one of the Big-Three is 313 (in Duke's Bioelectricitycourse), more students than typically enroll in the largest lecture class at many LACs. The first high-profile xMOOC, Introduction to Artificial Intelligence, was completed by an astounding 22,000 students, more than most LAC faculty will teach in an entire career (Jordan, 2013).

The scale of massive classes is both enticing and abhorrent to LAC faculty. The ability to reach thousands of students serves a dissemination mission, exposing people to our disciplines who might not otherwise have that opportunity. The diversity of student experiences and ideas in a massive course offers the possibility for discussion and cross-cultural connection impossible in our small and somewhat homogenous classrooms. Yet the massive scale of xMOOCs limits the amount and type of interaction between faculty and students. The mentorship and detailed feedback that is emblematic of the LAC experience is impossible with more than a few dozen students at a time. Coursera has replaced faculty feedback with peer grading, with predictably disappointing results (Watters, 2012a). These aspects of massive classes simply do not fit the mission or model of a LAC education.

Where scale would benefit LACs is not at the "massive" level, but at the small to mid-range level. Colleges with few faculty in certain specialties could band together to offer courses or even degrees with other institutions. While such consortial relationships have emerged among neighboring institutions (e.g., Five Colleges), the Internet obviates the need for physical proximity. The Associated Colleges of the South, which includes 16 colleges in 12 U.S. states, has experimented with cross-campus offerings in selected foreign languages and classics (King & Nanfito, 2012). Such collaborations could preserve courses as well as faculty lines in otherwise unsustainable disciplines.

Another interesting application of MOOCs for LACs lies in distributed or networked (as opposed to "massive") courses. A possible model is the upcoming Feminist Dialogues on Technology, a "distributed online collaborative course" or "DOCC" coordinated by Alexandra Juhasz of Pitzer College and Anne Balsamo of the University of Southern California that will link courses on every continent through a set of online experiences and modules. Distributed courses may offer the best of both worlds: local, face-to-face classes with strong faculty involvement that are connected with other classes to achieve economies of scale, geographic reach, and diversity of opinions.

One area where massive courses offer some advantage over face-to-face instruction is in learning analytics. It would take years in a LAC setting to assemble student data sets adequate to validate certain kinds of teaching techniques or learning objects. In a MOOC, such data can be collected and acted upon in weeks or less. In fact, EDUCAUSE (2012) predicts that MOOC "platforms may evolve from course-delivery systems toward adaptive learning platforms – systems that personalize the experience based on the learner's performance" (p. 1). However, Robbins (2013) worries that this data will be employed for marketing (in the manner of Facebook) rather than enhancing learning. At this writing, the OLI seems to be the only platform to harness these sorts of data for the immediate benefit of the learner.

What Could "Open" Mean for LACs?

"Free software" is a matter of liberty, not price. To understand the concept, you should think of "free" as in "free speech," not as in "free beer."(Stallman, 2013a, para. 3)

The word "open" is used in at least three different ways in these debates, most of which are only partly realized through the Big-Three MOOC platforms. The first interpretation of "open" is free of cost. At this point, the Big-Three MOOCs are free of charge to the student, though there is speculation about whether this is sustainable. Some institutions, like Antioch University, have entered into financial agreements with MOOC platforms to use MOOCs in credit-bearing courses or independent studies (Kolowich, 2012a). Some MOOCs charge for the completion certificate or to take a face-to-face test to certify what the student has learned. There is much speculation about the eventual business model of MOOCs. Of the Big-Three, both Coursera and Udacity are for-profit ventures, beholden to investors and eventually, shareholders. Questions abound regarding the business models that might emerge in the MOOC industry. It has yet to be determined if profits will come from student fees, university licenses (in the manner of software licenses), or selling student data (Robbins, 2013).

MOOCs are free to students because they are highly subsidized by institutions, foundation support (such as the Bill and Melinda Gates Foundation, Google, and others), and venture capital investment (Anders, 2013; Dunn, 2010). Few LACs are in a financial position to offer MOOCs of their own because of the cost of producing the video content, building or licensing the platform, and assuring that the online distribution of the course materials does not violate intellectual property law.

The second way of interpreting "open" has to do with barriers to entry. MOOCs have no admissions criteria. Anyone can sign up. Most LACs have extensive admissions criteria, including transcripts, essays, test scores, and often, interviews. The admissions process ostensibly limits the student body to those most likely to thrive. Advising and other student support services are in place to make sure that admitted students, particularly those deemed at risk, do not fall through the cracks. Once enrolled, students must fulfill prerequisites before moving on to more specialized courses. A student might be a junior before approaching a class in artificial intelligence, for example. Committing to an open course would mean abandoning the commitment to student success, a decision LACs would not take lightly.

The flip side of open enrollment is notoriously high dropout rates. Breslow et al. (2013) characterize the edX Circuits and Electronics course, which had a 5% completion rate, as "a funnel with students 'leaking out' at various points along the way" (p. 21). Low completion rates have been dismissed as simply part of online life, where most users are not active participants and most enrollees are not intending to complete the course. However, some proportion of students who do not complete a given MOOC "encountered difficulties ... that demotivated and damaged them, difficulties that caused them to believe that they weren't good enough; but we don't know who they are, and we don't know what those difficulties were" (Tracey, 2013, "The Danger of Expertise," para. 5).

The third way of interpreting "open" harkens back to Richard Stallman's admonition that truly free software "respects the users' essential freedoms: the freedom to run it, to study and change it, and to redistribute copies with or without changes" (Stallman, 2013b, para. 1). Using this definition, the degree of openness in MOOCs is highly variable. A few MOOC platforms offer some of their software for reuse or modification (see Khan Academy, Class2Go, Google Course Builder, and Stephen Downes' gRSShopper). The software running edX was released as open source in Summer 2013 (EdX, 2013).

As for content, some course videos used in MOOCs are available on YouTube as well and could be repurposed in other contexts. Many of the course readings are online and available for other uses. In the case of some edX courses, the materials have been online for years as part of MIT's OpenCourseWare. However, some MOOC platforms employ Terms of Service that restrict the use of the courses or materials in credit-bearing settings (Udas, 2012).

Of even greater concern is the degree to which xMOOCs lock down student data. In many cases, student work is difficult to export. Data generated from the students' interactions with the site are not transparent to the learner. Even aggregate data is only available when the instructor posts it online (for examples, see Devlin, 2013; Severance, 2012). With the exception of Udacity, which has built a portfolio site (Udacity.me) for showcasing student projects, xMOOC providers retain the role of arbiter and owner of student credentials.

Insofar as LACs venture into the MOOC movement, we must commit to openness. Just as LACs have begun to adopt open-access policies, requiring faculty to make their research available in online repositories (Miller, 2011), our institutions must affirm a commitment to open educational resources, adopting, investing in, and producing open content and open platforms, and ensuring that structures and norms established for MOOCs emphasize student ownership of their own work in the class and the assessment data generated. LACs should adopt and expand upon the Bill of Rights and Principles for Learning in the Digital Age (Brown et al., 2013) and integrate the oversight of open and online education into institutional governance structures.

What Could "Online" Mean for LACs?

Online education allows learning to occur outside the boundaries of place and time. Learning can take place outside a single classroom or building, and across great geographic and cultural distances. While students may be sitting alone at their computers, through online communication via text or multimedia, they can be connected to peers around the globe. Lovejoy (2012) offers an example of synchronous online discussion using the simultaneous editing function in Google Docs during a video webinar on Google Hangouts. He found that verbal and non-verbal cues were as intelligible and communication as rich in this format as they would have been in a face-to-face classroom, despite the fact that all of the participants were in different locations.

Even for LACs, which are traditionally residential institutions (where learning takes place in the classroom, library, and dormitory, but seldom off-campus), online tools may prove to be useful. Online communication could help campuses welcome students who have not yet matriculated (e.g., recruitment, admissions, new student orientation) or those who have graduated (e.g., alumni relations). Credit-bearing courses offered online could help students stay on track to graduate on time even while taking advantage of off-campus opportunities like study abroad and internships.

In addition to mediating communication across space, computing technologies afford students the possibility to complete tasks on their own schedule and sometimes at their own pace, opening up the possibility of student-directed learning both within and outside a traditional academic calendar. Online courses are doing away with traditional class formats, breaking videos of longer lectures into smaller pieces interspersed with comprehension questions or short application exercises (Kamenetz, 2012). This is similar to what some instructors are attempting to do with clicker and polling technologies in face-to-face classrooms. Students can even speed up or slow down these recorded lectures, or simply skim the transcript instead, though some argue that even these shorter learning units may be too long for the way people use the Internet today – with divided attention, often on mobile devices in public places (Manjoo, 2013; Tauber, 2013).

Computing technology is making it possible for students to receive immediate feedback on certain kinds of work, without waiting for the intervention of an instructor or human grader. Data about student use of course materials can be correlated with comprehension outcomes to offer insights about learning. Such analyses could help a student determine whether she retains more information by reading an article or watching a video about the material, or whether he is likely to score higher when taking an assessment in the evening or first thing in the morning. Computers are not well suited for assessing higher-order critical thinking or communication skills, but for content retention and mastery of rote skills, technology can potentially offer timely, more frequent, and more fine-grained feedback than a human instructor.

Directors of all three xMOOC providers tout the power of collecting user data to transform education, but exactly how learning analytics will be used to change the user experience in MOOCs is only starting to come to light (Chu, 2013; Mackay, 2013). However, user data in MOOCs is not available to the student, the instructors using the MOOC for blended learning, or in one reported case, even to the professor who developed the course (Guzdial, 2013).

While LAC faculty are embracing blended learning models, it is unlikely that an online-only approach will ever become the norm for these institutions. Even some of the messages coming from xMOOC providers themselves raise doubts about online-only learning. Examination of user data from the edX Circuits and Electronics course revealed that "those who worked on course material offline with a classmate or 'someone who teaches or has expertise' in the subject did better than those who did not" (Kolowich, 2013c, para. 2). Coursera announced in May 2013 new agreements with 10 state university systems to use Coursera content in support of, rather than to replace face-to-face instruction (Coursera, 2013).

What Could "Course" Mean for LACs?

We say explicitly that the content is the "McGuffin" – it is the thing that gets people together, gets them talking, gets them thinking in new ways ... As time goes by, the people at Codecademy and Udacity will understand that the community that forms around the courses or subjects are a lot more important than the content. (Downes, 2012, section 3, paras. 3, 8)

The Big-Three MOOCs emphasize the course as the unit of instruction, just as higher education is moving into a "post-course era" (Bass, 2012, p. 24). Over the last decade, most LACs have implemented some combination of linked or clustered courses, co-curricular and community tie-ins, student portfolios, research experiences, and other mechanisms for fomenting learning outside the traditional semester-long course. In fact, MOOC technologies may prove most useful to LACs precisely in the areas between and around courses.

Open online approaches have clear applications in the co-curriculum, particularly in new student orientation, leadership training, and other activities that are repeated annually for students from a variety of classes and majors. Academic applications that transcend the course include training in techniques or methods that span different classes and disciplines (e.g., information literacy or library instruction, lab safety or instrument calibration training). Online courses or modules may be employed for refresher or remedial courses for at-risk students or those whose mastery of prerequisite material is in doubt. Preliminary data show that online OLI modules helped at-risk students succeed in certain courses at Bryn Mawr, for example (Kolowich, 2012c).

A MOOC offered as a recruitment tool (King & Nanfito, 2012), or as a way of keeping alumni engaged, would employ learning as a way of building connections to the institution to those outside the residential student body. For example, Middlebury College has offered online courses for alumni on Social Entrepreneurship and the Poems of Robert Frost, while Amherst College maintains an online book club for alumni (Stillman, 2012). Online tools could be employed to foster true connections to local or global movements for social good (Davidson, 2012a). The most important way that LACs could employ MOOC technologies and structures is to help students form personal learning networks and communities of practice that can extend beyond their classrooms and campus and continue long after they have received their grade or even graduated.

Lifelong learning is not an abstract solitary endeavor, but a skill and value that is central to the mission of LACs. Laura Gibbs, online educator from The University of Oklahoma opines, "I think the real power of MOOCs is not as content delivery; I think the power of MOOCs is in getting people to create and collaborate together ... The missing ingredient is educational communities that really work" (deMause, 2013, para. 27).

Conclusion

Even as MOOCs drive the price of structured educational content downward and engender new forms of educational engagement and credentialing (Pappano, 2012), LACs have an opportunity to reaffirm our core strengths and value. The LAC experience has never been exclusively about disciplinary content. The definitive LAC experience revolves around the transformation of individuals, intellectually and emotionally, to produce exemplary citizens. By examining MOOCs in a thoughtful, proactive manner, LACs have an opportunity to understand their promise to enable students' lifelong learning and use these lessons to innovate the liberal arts. As Jonathan Marks of Ursinus College poignantly states:

Coursera and similar products are, for the most part, not designed to replace the kinds of undergraduate institutions that catch students during a period of momentous change in their lives, and respond to their need to discover and bring to completion their best mature selves ... [MOOCs] are in the self-improvement business. We are in the self-formation business. (Marks, 2012, para. 13)

References

An, Y.-J. (2010). Scaffolding wiki-based, ill-structured problem solving in an online environment. MERLOT Journal of Online Learning and Teaching, 6(4), 723-734. Retrieved from http://jolt.merlot.org/vol6no4/an_1210.htm

Anders, G. (2013, July 10). Coursera hits 4 million students – and triples its funding. Forbes. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/georgeanders/2013/07/10/coursera-hits-4-million-students-and-triples-its-funding

Baker, V. L., Baldwin, R. G., & Makker, S. (2012). Where are they now? Revisiting Breneman's study of liberal arts colleges. Liberal Education, 98(3), 48-53. Retrieved from http://www.aacu.org/liberaleducation/le-su12/baker_baldwin_makker.cfm

Bass, R. (2012). Disrupting ourselves: The problem of learning in higher education. EDUCAUSE Review, 47(2), 23-33. Retrieved from http://www.educause.edu/ero/article/disrupting-ourselves-problem-learning-higher-education

Breslow, L., Pritchard, D. E., DeBoer, J., Stump, G. S., Ho, A. D., & Seaton, D. T. (2013). Studying learning in the worldwide classroom: Research into edX's first MOOC. Research & Practice in Assessment, 8, 13-25. Retrieved from http://www.rpajournal.com/dev/wp-content/uploads/2013/05/SF2.pdf

Brooks, D. (2012, May 4). The campus tsunami. The New York Times, A29. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2012/05/04/opinion/brooks-the-campus-tsunami.html

Brown, J. S., Corcoran B., Davidson, C. N., Dierkes-Thrun, P., Edebohls, T., Gierl, M. J., ... Watters, A. (2013). A bill of rights and principles for learning in the digital age. Retrieved from http://www.hastac.org/forums/forum-bill-rights-and-principles-learning-digital-age

Chu, J. (2013, June 11). Data from edX’s first course offer preliminary insights into online learning. MIT News. Retrieved from http://web.mit.edu/newsoffice/2013/6002x-data-offer-insights-into-online-learning-0611.html

Cost, J., Miller, J., McLeod, J., St. George, M., Haro, P., & Mahler, J. (2013). Essay says faculty involved in MOOCs may be making rope for professional hangings. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/views/2013/01/14/essay-says-faculty-involved-moocs-may-be-making-rope-professional-hangings

Coursera. (2013, May 29). 10 US state university systems and public institutions join Coursera to explore mooc-based learning and collaboration on campus [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://blog.coursera.org/post/51696469860/10-us-state-university-systems-and-public-institutions

Cusumano, M. A. (2013). Are the costs of "free" too high in online education? Communications of the ACM, 56(4), 26-28. doi:10.1145/2436256.2436264

Daly, J. (2013, January 11). Blended learning is a comfortable alternative to MOOCs and online learning. EdTech Magazine. Retrieved from http://www.edtechmagazine.com/higher/article/2013/01/blended-learning-comfortable-alternative-moocs-and-online-learning-infographic

Davidson, C. N. (2012a, May 9). Why flip the classroom when we can make it do cartwheels? Co.Exist. Retrieved from http://www.fastcoexist.com/1679807/why-flip-the-classroom-when-we-can-make-it-do-cartwheels

Davidson, C. N. (2012b, October 1). What can MOOCs teach us about learning? [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.hastac.org/blogs/cathy-davidson/2012/10/01/what-can-moocs-teach-us-about-learning

Davidson, C. N. (2013, January 23). Bill of rights and principles for learning in a digital age: Full document plus back story [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.hastac.org/blogs/cathy-davidson/2013/01/23/bill-rights-and-principles-learning-digital-age-full-document-plus-b

deMause, N. (2013, January 2). Free online classes: Unlocking the ivory tower. Village Voice. Retrieved from http://www.villagevoice.com/2013-01-02/news/free-online-education/full/

Devlin, K. (2013, March 2). MOOCs and the myths of dropout rates and certification [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/dr-keith-devlin/moocs-and-the-myths-of-dr_b_2785808.html

Downes, S. (2011, January 5). "Connectivism" and connective knowledge [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/stephen-downes/connectivism-and-connecti_b_804653.html

Downes, S. (2012, April 23). The rise of MOOCs [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.downes.ca/post/57911

Dunn, J. (2010, September 24). Google awards $2 million prize to Khan Academy. Edudemic. Retrieved from http://www.edudemic.com/2010/09/google-awards-2-million-prize-to-khan-academy/

Edmundson, M. (2012, July 20). The trouble with online education. The New York Times, A23. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/20/opinion/the-trouble-with-online-education.html

EDUCAUSE. (2012). What campus leaders need to know about MOOCs. Retrieved from http://net.educause.edu/ir/library/pdf/PUB4005.pdf

EdX. (2013). EdX builds community of developers for its online and blended learning platform [Press release]. Retrieved from https://www.edx.org/alert/edx-builds-community-developers/944

Falk, A. (2012, August 28). In defense of the living, breathing professor. The Wall Street Journal. Retrieved from http://online.wsj.com/article/SB10000872396390444327204577615592746799900.html

Guzdial, M. (2013, June 11). MOOCs today are about less data for the teacher [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://computinged.wordpress.com/2013/06/11/moocs-today-are-about-less-data-for-the-teacher/

Harden, N. (2013). The end of the university as we know it. The American Interest, 8(3), 54-62. Retrieved from http://www.the-american-interest.com/article.cfm?piece=1352

Horn, M., & Christensen, C. (2013, February 20). Beyond the buzz, where are MOOCs really going? [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.wired.com/opinion/2013/02/beyond-the-mooc-buzz-where-are-they-going-really/

Jaschik, S. (2012, October 11). Study finds that liberal arts colleges are disappearing. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/10/11/study-finds-liberal-arts-colleges-are-disappearing

Jordan, K. (2013, February 13). MOOC completion rates: The data. Retrieved from http://www.katyjordan.com/MOOCproject.html

Judson, B. (2013, May 21). Imminent chaos [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.huffingtonpost.com/bruce-judson/imminent-chaos_b_3312708.html

Kamenetz, A. (2010). DIY U: Edupunks, edupreneurs, and the coming transformation of higher education. White River Junction, VT: Chelsea Green.

Kamenetz, A. (2012, August 8). How Coursera, a free online education service, will school us all. Retrieved from http://www.fastcompany.com/3000042/how-coursera-free-online-education-service-will-school-us-all

Kiley, K. (2012, November 19). Liberal arts colleges rethink their messaging in the face of criticism. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/11/19/liberal-arts-colleges-rethink-their-messaging-face-criticism

King, W. J., & Nanfito, M. (2012, November 29). Essay on the challenges posed by MOOCs to liberal arts colleges. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/views/2012/11/29/essay-challenges-posed-moocs-liberal-arts-colleges

Kolowich, S. (2012a, October 29). Coursera strikes MOOC licensing deal with Antioch University. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/10/29/coursera-strikes-mooc-licensing-deal-antioch-university

Kolowich, S. (2012b, November 8). At EDUCAUSE, a discussion about OER. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/11/08/educause-discussion-about-oer

Kolowich, S. (2012c, June 29). Liberal arts college explore uses of 'blended' online learning. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/06/29/liberal-arts-college-explore-uses-blended-online-learning

Kolowich, S. (2013a, January 23). "Bill of rights" seeks to protect students' interests as online learning expands. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/article/Bill-of-Rights-Seeks-to/136783/

Kolowich, S. (2013b, February 4). Georgia Tech and Coursera try to recover from MOOC stumble [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/georgia-tech-and-coursera-try-to-recover-from-mooc-stumble/42167

Kolowich, S. (2013c, June 7). MOOC students who got offline help scored higher, study finds [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/mooc-students-who-got-offline-help-scored-higher-study-finds

Lenzner, R., & Johnson, S. S. (1997). Seeing things as they really are. Forbes, 159(5), 122-128. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/forbes/1997/0310/5905122a.html

Lovejoy, D. (2012). The online face-to-face classroom [Video file]. Retrieved from http://www.vimeo.com/27276956

Lukes, D. (2012, September 15). The great MOOC slander? Realities and narratives of education and learning [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.researchity.net/2012/09/15/the-great-mooc-slander-realities-and-narratives-of-education-and-learning/

Mackay, R. F. (2013, April 11). Learning analytics at Stanford takes huge leap forward with MOOCs. Stanford Report. Retrieved from http://news.stanford.edu/news/2013/april/online-learning-analytics-041113.html

Manjoo, F. (2013, June 6). How people read online: Why you won't finish this article. Slate. Retrieved from http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/technology/2013/06/how_people_read_online_why_you_won_t_finish_this_article.single.html

Marks, J. (2012, October 5). Why MOOCs won't replace traditional instruction. Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/views/2012/10/05/why-moocs-wont-replace-traditional-instruction-essay

Marques, J., & McGuire, R. (2013, June 7). What is a massive open online course anyway? MN+R attempts a definition. MOOC News & Reviews. Retrieved from http://www.moocnewsandreviews.com/what-is-a-massive-open-online-course-anyway-attempting-definition

Mazel. (2012, October 27). Re: The onus of education [Web log comment]. Retrieved from http://moreorlessbunk.wordpress.com/2012/10/24/the-onus-of-education/

Michels, S. (2013, January 8). How free online courses are changing the traditional liberal arts education. Retrieved from http://www.pbs.org/newshour/bb/education/jan-june13/online_01-08.html

Miller, J. (2011). Open access and liberal arts colleges: Looking beyond research institutions. College & Research Libraries News, 72(1), 16-30. Retrieved from http://crln.acrl.org/content/72/1/16.full

Oremus, W. (2012, July 18). Coursera, Udacity, edX: Will free online Ivy League courses end the era of expensive higher ed?. Slate. Retrieved from http://www.slate.com/articles/technology/future_tense/2012/07/coursera_udacity_edx_will_free_online_ivy_league_courses_end_the_era_of_expensive_higher_ed_.html

Pappano, L. (2012, November 2). The year of the MOOC. The New York Times, ED26. Retrieved from http://www.nytimes.com/2012/11/04/education/edlife/massive-open-online-courses-are-multiplying-at-a-rapid-pace.html

Robbins, J. (2013, March 25). The ethics of MOOCs. [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/blogs/sounding-board/ethics-moocs

Scholz, C. (2012, October 11). Some thoughts on video and teaching [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://claudiascholz.wordpress.com/2012/10/11/video-in-teaching/

Schmidt, P. (2013, June 12). AAUP sees MOOCs as spawning new threats to professors' intellectual property. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/article/AAUP-Sees-MOOCs-as-Spawning/139743/

Severance, C. (2012, September 30). Visualizing the geographic distribution of my Coursera course [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.dr-chuck.com/csev-blog/2012/09/geographic-distribution-of-my-coursera-course/

Shirky, C. (2012, November 12). Napster, Udacity, and the academy [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.shirky.com/weblog/2012/11/napster-udacity-and-the-academy/

Siemens, G. (2011, September 15). Duplication theory of educational value [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.elearnspace.org/blog/2011/09/15/duplication-theory-of-educational-value/

Siemens, G. (2012, June 3). What is the theory that underpins our MOOCs? [Web log post] Retrieved from http://www.elearnspace.org/blog/2012/06/03/what-is-the-theory-that-underpins-our-moocs/

Siemens, G., & Matheos, K.. (2010). Systemic changes in higher education. in education, 16(1), 3-18. Retrieved from http://www.ineducation.ca/index.php/ineducation/article/view/42/503

Skorton, D., & Altschuler, G. (2013, January 28). MOOCs: A college education online? Forbes. Retrieved from http://www.forbes.com/sites/collegeprose/2013/01/28/moocs-a-college-education-online/

Stallman, R. (2013a). What is free software? Retrieved from http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/free-sw.html

Stallman, R. (2013b). Why open source misses the point of free software. Retrieved from http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/open-source-misses-the-point.html

Stillman, I. (2012). College offers online education to alumni. The Middlebury Campus, 111(8), 1-2. Retrieved from http://www.middleburycampus.com/article/college-offers-online-education-to-alumni/

Tauber, T. (2013, March 21). The dirty little secret of online learning: Students are bored and dropping out. Quartz. Retrieved from http://www.qz.com/65408/the-dirty-little-secret-of-online-learning-students-are-bored-and-dropping-out/

Tilsley, A. (2012, December 6). Unlikely pairing? Inside Higher Ed. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/news/2012/12/06/wellesley-and-wesleyan-hope-moocs-will-inform-campus-based-teaching

Tracey, N. (2013, June 11). The value of a good whinge – do MOOC forums stifle P2P learning? MOOC News & Reviews. Retrieved from http://www.moocnewsandreviews.com/value-of-a-good-whinge-do-mooc-forums-stifle-p2p-learning

Udas, K. (2012, November 15). Never mind Antioch, what is Coursera up to? [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.kenudas.com/2012/11/never-mind-antioch-what-is-coursera-up.html

Watters, A. (2012a, August 27). The problems with peer grading in Coursera [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.insidehighered.com/blogs/hack-higher-education/problems-peer-grading-coursera

Watters, A. (2012b, December 3). Top ed-tech trends of 2012: MOOCs [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.hackeducation.com/2012/12/03/top-ed-tech-trends-of-2012-moocs/

Acknowledgments

In Fall 2012, Trinity University's Office of the Vice President for Information Resources provided a pilot grant to support a conversation about MOOCs on Trinity's campus. Participants in this pilot were Dr. Jenny Browne, Dr. Jennifer Steele, Dr. Mark Lewis, and Dr. Sean Connin. The Associated Colleges of the South Faculty Advancement Program provided a grant to expand this conversation to other campuses in the consortium. Participants in this ongoing, second phase include Forrest Stonedahl of Centre College, Bryan Bibb and Mary Fairbairn of Furman University, Chris Campolo and Gabriel Ferrer of Hendrix College, Richard Lu of Spelman College, and Aaron Delwiche and Dennis Ugolini of Trinity University. Both projects are documented on a group blog and online panel discussions. Guest panelists included Wayne Anderson of the Associated Colleges of the South, Audree Hernandez of AdviseTX, Matt Barsalou of Trinity's Admissions department, and Gundega Dekena of Udacity. These conversations have shaped the author's thinking about MOOCs. The ACS grant supported part of the literature collection presented in this position paper.

The author is indebted to Laura Gibbs for her many insights into online learning and for her comments on this paper. Additional valued comments came from Vidya Ananthanarayanan, Robert Chapman, Rebecca Frost Davis, Aaron Delwiche, Lisa Jasinski, and Charles White. Sean Connin made detailed revisions to the introduction and conclusion.

Responsibility for any failings in this article remains with the author.


View the original article here

Patterns of Engagement in Connectivist MOOCs

         Patterns of Engagement in Connectivist MOOCs


Colin Milligan

Research Fellow
Caledonian Academy
Glasgow Caledonian University
Glasgow G4 0BA UK
colin.milligan@gcu.ac.uk

Allison Littlejohn
Professor and Director
Caledonian Academy
Glasgow Caledonian University
Glasgow G4 0BA UK
allison.littlejohn@gcu.ac.uk

Anoush Margaryan
Senior Lecturer
Caledonian Academy
Glasgow Caledonian University
Glasgow G4 0BA UK
anoush.margaryan@gcu.ac.uk

Abstract

Connectivist massive open online courses (cMOOCs) represent an important new pedagogical approach ideally suited to the network age. However, little is known about how the learning experience afforded by cMOOCs is suited to learners with different skills, motivations, and dispositions. In this study, semi-structured interviews were conducted with 29 participants on the Change11 cMOOC. These accounts were analyzed to determine patterns of engagement and factors affecting engagement in the course. Three distinct types of engagement were recognized – active participation, passive participation, and lurking. In addition, a number of key factors that mediated engagement were identified including confidence, prior experience, and motivation. This study adds to the overall understanding of learning in cMOOCs and provides additional empirical data to a nascent research field. The findings provide an insight into how the learning experience afforded by cMOOCs suits the diverse range of learners that may coexist within a cMOOC. These insights can be used by designers of future cMOOCs to tailor the learning experience to suit the diverse range of learners that may choose to learn in this way.

Keywords: massive open online course (MOOC), connectivist massive open online course (cMOOC), connectivism, lurking, networks, active participation, passive participation

Introduction

Pedagogical models of learning online have been extensively theorized, particularly with respect to the interrelationship of technology and pedagogy (Anderson & Dron, 2010; Garrison, 1997; Kanuka & Anderson, 1999). As we approach near ubiquity of networked connections between people, content, and tools (reflecting the "networked society" described by Castells, 1996), researchers such as George Siemens have proposed new pedagogical approaches based on the principles of connectivism (Siemens, 2005), through which learning is viewed as residing in the connections that exist between people and digital artifacts within this ubiquitous network. One example of connectivist pedagogy in action is the massive open online course (MOOC) format pioneered by Siemens along with his colleague Stephen Downes, first in the Connectivism and Connected Knowledge 2008 (CCK08) course (Downes, 2008) and thereafter in many subsequent courses including the Change11 course that forms the basis of this study. These MOOCs, known as connectivist or cMOOCs, focus on knowledge creation and generation rather than "knowledge duplication" (Siemens, 2012, para. 3). In cMOOCs, the learners take a greater role in shaping their learning experiences than in traditional online courses, while facilitators focus on fostering a space for learning connections to occur. While cMOOCs can empower learners to take control of their learning, there remains a question about how the learning experience afforded by these cMOOCs is suited to learners with different skills, motivations, and dispositions. As cMOOCs are a relatively new phenomenon, there are few studies that have explored these issues (e.g., Kop & Fournier, 2010; Mackness, Mak, & Williams, 2010). The overall aim of this study is to address this lack of empirical data.

This study focuses on two research questions:

What patterns of engagement exist within the Change11 cMOOC course?What principal factors mediate this engagement?By gaining a deeper insight into the patterns of engagement in cMOOC courses, this study seeks to provide an insight into how future cMOOCs can be designed to better support the learning needs and expectations of the wide range of learners that coexist within cMOOCs. The paper begins with a review of relevant literature, focusing on existing research examining the learning experience in cMOOCs. Next, the Change11 course context is described, followed by a description of the methodology adopted in this study and the sample studied. The study findings are then presented and discussed. Finally, recognizing the limitations of this study, the implications of these findings for research and practice are discussed, particularly in relation to the design of future cMOOC learning experiences.

Literature Review

Connectivist MOOCs emerged initially as an instantiation of the pedagogic principles of connectivism developed by Siemens and Downes, and their first MOOC, CCK08, naturally explored the topic of connectivism as it attracted participation from learning researchers and practitioners who had been following the evolution of these ideas. Subsequent large scale cMOOCs, such as Personal Learning Environments Networks and Knowledge (PLENK 2010) and Connectivism and Connected Knowledge 2011 (CCK11), have continued in the same vein, exploring similar topics and attracting participants eager to experience the cMOOC format as well as the course content itself. This has led to the emergence of a rather unusual research base where a small amount of empirical research, published in niche journals and peer reviewed conferences, is supplemented by a large body of more anecdotal and reflective research published outside the traditional peer-reviewed journal system. To date, the key empirical research has been carried out by three groups of researchers: Fini (2009), Mackness et al. (2010), and Kop and her colleagues (Kop, 2011; Kop & Fournier, 2010; Kop, Fournier, & Mak, 2011), exploring the cMOOCs listed above.

Software tools for discovery, connection, and co-creation are a fundamental component of cMOOCs, together constituting the platform through which the course is delivered. In his study, Fini (2009) focused on the technological dimension of CCK08, exploring participants' perceptions of the course toolset as well as their views on the course. The research showed that one course component, The Daily newsletter, was valued by participants who used it as a tool to filter and organize their participation in the course, but that other tools, such as the discussion forums provided by Moodle, were viewed less positively. In addition, Fini's research highlighted digital literacy and English language proficiency as key skills needed to participate effectively in the course. The study also provided evidence of different behavior patterns being exhibited by course participants based on their personal objectives, backgrounds, and levels of engagement. As the first cMOOC, CCK08 can be seen as a prototype; and it is interesting to note that subsequent cMOOCs designed by Siemens and Downes adopted different toolsets, specifically ending the use of Moodle as a locus for discussion forums. This had the effect of moving discussion and interaction to blog posts and other spaces controlled by the learners, following the concept of the personal learning environment introduced by Wilson et al. (2007).

Mackness et al. (2010) also studied the CCK08 course, focusing on the four key characteristics of connectivist online courses suggested by Downes (2009): autonomy, diversity, openness, and connectedness/interactivity. Mackness et al.'s study, conducted by survey and e-mail interview, identified inherent tensions between these characteristics. The presence of these tensions raises the question of whether all four characteristics can be accommodated within the concept of a course in the traditionally understood sense, where the term creates expectations of structure, moderation, and support.

Research by Kop and associated researchers focused on the PLENK2010 cMOOC and carried on to examine the CCK11 cMOOC. This research focuses on the learning experience, and in particular on self-directed learning, asking whether cMOOCs facilitate the occurrence of self-directed learning. Kop and Fournier (2010) used quantitative (surveys) and qualitative (ethnography) data, supplemented by social network analysis to develop an understanding of autonomous learning within the PLENK2010 cMOOC. The research used Bouchard's (2009) four-dimensional model of learner control (conative, algorithmic, semiotic, and economic) to explore how motivation and confidence, the structure of learning, the delivery environment, and the perceived value of learning influenced learning strategies used by participants within the course. The study highlights additional factors necessary for learning in cMOOC type environments, principally the critical literacies essential to efficiently evaluate the large quantities of information present in a cMOOC – including an open mindset, the ability to learn cooperatively with others, and heightened critical analysis skills. In another paper based on the same study, Kop (2011) focuses on activities typical of cMOOC (or network)-based learning: aggregation, relation, creation, and sharing. The active and collaborative nature of these activities, similar to other classifications, such as the 4C learning behaviors (consume, connect, create, and contribute) identified by Littlejohn, Milligan, and Margaryan (2011), emphasize the importance of learning as a participatory process (Sfard, 1998) in the context of networked informal learning. Kop (2011) argues that to learn effectively in connectivist environments, learners must have key critical literacies such as those outlined above to be able to engage and participate, and have the confidence and competence to use the tools that mediate the key learning interactions that occur.

The Kop (2011) study also highlights the different types of learning approaches observed in the PLENK2010 cMOOC, recognizing the large number of lurkers (Rovai, 2000) who were present in these courses. In a third paper based on PLENK2010 but also incorporating data from the CCK11 cMOOC, Kop et al. (2011) return to the question of the underlying technology and explore whether specific learning environment designs can support effective learning in cMOOCs, arguing that structures must, at least to some extent, be emergent, and owned by the participants rather than imposed by the facilitators.
These studies have begun to provide a base of empirical data representing the learning that occurs in cMOOCs, but there is widespread recognition that more empirical research is urgently needed, particularly given the current widespread interest in the broad spectrum of MOOCs (Daniel, 2012). There is still a lack of data, drawn from too few courses, with a limited range of methodologies. This study seeks to build on these studies, examining a different course, the Change11 cMOOC, and using a different method (interview and survey instrument combined), to develop a greater understanding of the different patterns of engagement that coexist within cMOOC courses. Of particular interest is the nature of the networks these participants utilize to support their learning and the different factors that affect participation and engagement.

Course Context

The Change11 course was a large-scale cMOOC running from September 2011 to May 2012, organized and facilitated by George Siemens, Stephen Downes, and Dave Cormier. Over 35 weeks, participants were introduced to the work of a range of instructional design researchers and practitioners. Registration was open and course delivery was supported through a variety of technologies, principally a daily e-mail newsletter and online synchronous seminars delivered via the Elluminate platform. The course attracted more than 2,300 participants. An e-mail newsletter called The Daily communicated course announcements and content from presenters, while also aggregating blog posts and tweets from participants marked with the hashtag "#change11." This hashtag, along with self-organized spaces such as a Change11 group on Facebook and a multi-author blog associated with the course, provided a universal means of discovery of course related blog posts and content.

Method

The findings reported here represent one component of a larger study examining self-regulated learning behavior within the Change11 cMOOC. Participants for the study were recruited via an invitation and study description included as the first item in The Daily e-mail sent to everyone registered for the Change11 cMOOC during Week 17 of the course. Thirty-five individuals from a total of 2,300 registered learners agreed to participate. Study participants were initially invited to complete a short online survey. The survey used items adapted from a number of existing self-report self-regulated learning (SRL) instruments (Barnard, Lan, Paton, & Lai, 2009; Gijbels, Raemdonck, & Vervecken, 2010; Maclellan & Soden, 2006; Pintrich, Smith, García, & McKeachie, 1991; Schraw & Dennison, 1994; Toering, Elferink-Gemser, Jonker, van Heuvelen, & Visscher, 2012) to enable the researchers to derive SRL profiles for each participant. The survey also collected demographic information (country of residence, employer, and discipline/field) and asked respondents about their experience of previous MOOCs. From the initial sample of 35, 29 study participants were able to subsequently take part in a one-hour semi-structured interview via Skype, which explored various aspects of participation including motivation, goal-setting, and planning strategies, as well as exploring study participants' existing and emergent learning networks, their use of tools to support their learning, and their perceptions of their own participation in the course. Interviews were transcribed and stripped of identifying information. Transcripts were analyzed and a combination of predefined and emergent codes used to categorize the data. Ethical standards for the study were adopted in accordance with local regulations: all participants were provided with information about the study and how their data would be used, and were assured confidentiality and anonymity in any published work. Participants were asked to formally indicate their consent and were free to withdraw at any point.

Sample

Twenty-nine course participants out of 2,300 registrants on the course were interviewed in this study. Although a small number as a proportion of the total registrants, the sample is robust and appropriate for a qualitative study where a minimum sample of 12 is considered acceptable (Guest, Bunce, & Johnson, 2006). Everyone registered for the course received the e-mail that included the invitation to participate, so all those registrants who were active at Week 17 (midway through the course) would see the invitation. One limitation of the sampling procedure used is that anyone who had stopped actively following the course by this point would not have participated in the study. This limitation will be discussed in the results and discussion sections. The overarching topic of the cMOOC was instructional design, and all participants were either learning professionals (24, employed as lecturers, teachers, or instructional designers), or graduate students (five). Twelve of 24 learning professional participants were from the higher education sector, while 11 were drawn from the K-12 or community college sector. One participant was employed to support learning in a workplace outside the education sector. Eighteen of 29 participants were female, with 11 being male. Twenty of 29 participants had studied in previous cMOOCs.

Results

This study addressed two research questions: "What patterns of engagement exist within the Change11 cMOOC course?" and "What principal factors mediate this engagement?" These questions are now addressed in turn.

Patterns of Engagement

The semi-structured interview questions explored the topic of engagement in the course in a number of ways. Questions regarding motivation to do the course were complemented by questions exploring participation behavior. Finally, some questions were designed to probe the makeup of each respondent's personal learning network (their primary networks). Analyzing the responses to these questions allowed the authors to detect a number of different patterns of engagement with the course that are presented in this section.

Three distinct levels of engagement exhibited by the participants were identified in this study: Active participants, lurkers, and passive participants. Within these three levels, one key internal difference was observed: the location of the primary network for each individual, which might be internal or external to the course. Table 1 shows the number of participants in each category.

Table 1. Engagement and primary networks for the Change11 MOOC

Primary Network for this CourseThe different categories are described in turn below.

Active participants. The first group identified by this analysis (12 of 29) was a group described as active participants. These participants have adapted well to the connectivist pedagogy of cMOOCs, maintaining active blogs and Twitter accounts, actively and regularly discussing the course. All these active participants had formed wholly or primarily internal networks, connecting with other learners through Twitter and blogs. The live Elluminate sessions represented a key opportunity to make connections and widen their network. One participant, from South America, described the buzz of the chat sessions accompanying the live Elluminate sessions as follows: "You can read the comments of people who are participating from different places and they give links to things that they are doing or they think while you hear what is happening" (Participant 20). Not all active participants attended the live sessions (for reasons such as impractical scheduling in their time zone), but these sessions did seem to be an important focus for those who could attend.

Active participants were highly motivated to persist with the course and were able to overcome challenges in the course that might have proved a barrier to participation for others. For example one participant described how the live Elluminate sessions were sometimes confusing, and how she overcame this challenge:

"Yes I do, I found that when I was coming in cold to those speakers I was totally lost. So I had to come up with some short, sharp, effective strategies. First one being I'll check out the person on YouTube, I need to be able to get into the same space about what they're talking about, so at least I've got some sense of who they are and what they're going on about. So that was one strategy I used." (Participant 9)

Most active participants were energetic bloggers and Twitter users, using these tools as their main mechanism of communication. Active participants recognized that full participation entailed more than merely broadcasting ideas (creating tweets and blog posts) and had developed strategies to encourage connection with other participants through commenting on other blogs. One participant described how the majority of her contributions were made as responses to other posts: "I have no idea how scattered I am across this MOOC, I have no idea how many contributions I've made, 30? 50? I've got a lot of replies" (Participant 5). This participant went on to describe how she sought to encourage interaction: "So I usually end a reply on an open end. That's one of my, you know, I structure it that way" (Participant 5).

Aside from writing and commenting on blogs and following Twitter, active participants with primarily internal networks described other spaces that were particularly conducive to connection and collaboration. These spaces, established by the participants rather than facilitators, became the most vibrant community spaces for the course. One such space was Facebook, as described by one participant: "I found the Facebook group was where I really engaged with the course and teamed up with a few people there and it was good" (Participant 8). The same participant highlighted the value of some particularly active participants who could be inspirational to the rest of the cohort: "Oh there's some people who are everywhere you turn in the Change11 MOOC: there's this group of people who are inspirational, just phenomenal the way they just keep going and they know their way around it" (Participant 8).

While the majority (nine of 12) of active participants appeared to segregate their internal and external networks (effectively treating the Change11 as a closed course) a small number of participants (three of 12) seemed to have merged these networks to some extent – recognizing the artificiality of trying to separate different networks. One participant described how she actively sought to bring the two networks together when it was appropriate to do so:

"I try to think about taking what I find relevant in the [MOOC] and specifically advocating for it within [my external network] as well. So I do cross-pollinate like that. ... I hope that's helpful to people who normally wouldn't see this kind of stuff." (Participant 25)

The same participant summed up the value of being active in the course as follows, referring both to her motivation and to the development of her digital skills:
"I've gone further with the tools than I had in the past, so getting really familiar with Twitter, with Facebook, with LinkedIn, with Diigo for social bookmarking, for blogging, for setting up a blog ... and I remember when I crossed the threshold of having 1000 views ... yeahhh! It felt good to see the attraction, to have my work referred elsewhere." (Participant 25)

While a connectivist MOOC should cater to all types of participants, active participants represent the ideal learners for this type of course design: not just consuming content, but connecting with others, creating new content, and contributing these new resources back into the course for others to utilize. In fact, without a critical mass of active participants, a connectivist course would fail. Lurkers. The largest category of engagement identified in this analysis was of lurkers (13 of 29). These participants were actively following the course but did not actively engage with other learners within it. These participants were by no means disengaged with the course, or unhappy with their position. Instead, lurking was an active choice for them. One participant offered the view that "lurking is actually hugely beneficial" (Participant 18), before going on to describe how the course content was effectively new knowledge filtered by the course organizers and therefore had "more value than something I randomly come across on the Internet" (Participant 18).

As before, different types of lurking behavior were seen, based on the networks (external or internal) these lurkers engaged with. We saw three subcategories: (1) those who felt they did not engage with any network at all (four of 13); (2) those who engaged with networks external to the Change11 course but not with the internal networks (four of 13); and finally, (3) those who silently participated in internal networks (five of 13). Four of the participants did not engage with any network at all, and had a simple explanation for their behavior: that they were not interested in engaging with others to learn. One explained: "I guess I tend to be a loner and I've done more lurking and I'm quite happy lurking, I think it's an honourable profession" (Participant 21), while another simply stated: "I have not created any links with people, I have not said who I am and what I'm doing" (Participant 15). Even though this group had not engaged with others, the fact that they were still following the course after almost five months shows that the course format is compatible with their needs.

Four participants maintained a complex position whereby they were inactive within the course, but actively shared ideas from the course externally. As one participant reported:

"I'm going out to the MOOC and lurking and getting lots of great interesting ideas and I'm bringing these back to some of my home based networks, both ones within my institution but also ones within my network that I've built up professionally." (Participant 1)

A second participant made a similar point:
"I'm more or less like what do you call? A lurker and not very active ... I'm always invisible and the reason is that the way I've been using the MOOC is to put into things that I'm doing. Like I said, to be a network mentor." (Participant 17)

Both these participants had a clear understanding of why they wanted to participate in Change11. They wanted to apply the new knowledge they had gained to improve their own practice. Similarly, a third lurker in this group had shared her experience in the Change11 MOOC with colleagues at her own institution, while showing little engagement with the course community.

Finally, a group of five participants (all of whom self-identified as lurkers) silently participated in internal networks but did not contribute to the course in any way. Their behavior appears to be motivated by lack of confidence. For example, one participant provided the following explanation for her lurking:

"No, because I basically, I got caught up in my own learning and I didn't feel ... [it was worthwhile to contribute my] limited knowledge about what was being discussed. Beyond saying 'oh that resonates with me' well how many times have MOOC'ers said that! And I know it does resonate, but beyond that I couldn't add anything new." (Participant 18)

Others saw silent participation as a step to more full participation in future courses, acknowledging that in this course, they did not quite have the confidence to participate actively. As one participant remarked: "I did write a blog post but I conveniently wrote it somewhere no one would read [it] and I wrote it in [not English], so more like cathartic to me, rather than me putting it out in the open" (Participant 4). These silent lurkers saw a connection between level of participation and their success as learners, as exemplified by this quote from one participant: "I would have felt I accomplished more if I had personally networked and participated more" (Participant 33).

The lurkers category is somewhat complex as it includes a spectrum of participants from those who lacked the confidence to participate, to those who were so confident they didn't need to participate in the course in what they might regard as "the traditional manner." What links all these lurkers is that a cMOOC format works for them – they have the skills to leverage what they want from the course, on their terms.

Passive participants. The final group identified was the passive participant group. This category of four participants was united by their apparent frustration or dissatisfaction with the course. For one participant, the connectivist nature of the course just did not seem appropriate, as this extensive quote illustrates:
"I wrangled with the whole issue of connectivism, not the concept so much, as my ability to do that, to connect with others, and so I think I was looking inward a little bit and had some difficulty there as to whether or not I could succeed in that aspect as a learner, to be able to really make connections with other people on a deep level. I mean, sure, I can read other people's blogs and that's not a problem, and I comment occasionally, but as far as really putting my ideas out there in the open in my own blog to be trampled on, you know there's a bit of fear there I think that I have and so that has been difficult for me, to really put my ideas out there, which I know is good from the aspect of I could get feedback and learn from that, but there's still something in me that says what do I know? Who am I to contribute my thoughts to the world? I'm just this little person over here." (Participant 12)

Another member of this passive group failed to see the inherent value of learning through the network but instead seemed to be looking for a more formal course:
"I selected the MOOC because it was being led by a well-known, well established, very experienced names [sic] and that's actually the secret, I realize now that what I'm looking for when I'm looking to make a jump in development is actually more guidance rather than freeform learning. The whole point is I can do the freeform anywhere, anytime, 24 hours a day on the net." (Participant 23)

A third member expressed her frustration with not connecting: "I'm not really sure how to find a group of people online who really want to learn about what I most want to learn about" (Participant 13).

The invitation to participate in this study was sent out in Week 17 of the course. It is therefore surprising that these passive participants had persisted with the course to this point; perhaps they could be categorized as dissatisfied lurkers (in contrast to the satisfied lurkers identified above). Despite extensive efforts by the course organizers to accommodate learners of all types in the Change11 cMOOC, via videos and guidance in the orientation week of the course, it seems that the cMOOC format is not suitable for every learner. It is also important to acknowledge that it is likely that many course participants had dropped out by Week 17, and that it is this category of passive participants – whose needs are clearly not being met – who are most likely to have dropped out and are therefore underrepresented in this study.

Factors Affecting Engagement

Our second research question asked, "What principal factors mediate engagement?" From the accounts of engagement in the Change11 cMOOC that were collected, some key factors affecting engagement in this cMOOC can be identified:

Confidence. One key factor evident in the responses of both passive participants and lurkers relates to their confidence levels. Here, for example, a participant describes how her lack of confidence discouraged her from sharing her bookmarks socially:
"I actually did sign up with Diigo thinking right, this is it, I'm going to throw myself in. But once I was in the MOOC and running the idea, I actually felt almost as though I would be, instead of sharing with others, I was going to be simply showing my ignorance, even in terms of what I was selecting and why I was selecting it." (Participant 23)

Elsewhere, numerous participants described writing blog posts but not publishing them – in this way they gained the benefit of working through ideas, without having to expose those ideas to a potentially critical audience. Prior experience. An important factor was participants' prior experience. Twenty of 29 participants had previously participated in a cMOOC. As shown in Table 2, all but one of the active participants had previously participated in another cMOOC, while none of the four passive participants had previously participated in a cMOOC. Learning in a cMOOC is fundamentally different from learning in a formal course, and requires some adjustment.Table 2. Participant group by previous cMOOC experience

Participation in Previous cMOOCsMotivation. Finally, motivation was identified as an important determinant of engagement. Several of the active participants described a clear aim associated with their participation in the Change11 cMOOC. For example, this participant had clear ambitions to change his/her practice: "The ultimate aim of participating in this MOOC is to see how I can completely change the way that I teach and illustrate through example how others could do the same" (Participant 32). In contrast, passive participants had less well formed aims, as illustrated by this quote:
"Maybe that's part of my problem that I didn't maybe have a strong enough particular aim, like I'm interested in the idea of understanding better how they work, but I'm actually more interested in learning about other things that are nothing to do with online learning." (Participant 23)

Discussion and Conclusion

Active participants represent the key group in a cMOOC. A successful course becomes the content that these participants create and share, far more so than the live presentations and course readings. Moreover, the network of connections with other learners is something that can persist long after a cMOOC has ended. The more active or experienced members of the group provide a model for those who are less experienced, and are instrumental in creating the emergent spaces supporting connectedness and interactivity (Downes, 2009), which Kop et al. (2011) have argued are essential to successful connectivist learning environments. One key observation from this study is that all but one of the active participants had previously participated in at least one other cMOOC, while none of the four passive participants had participated in a cMOOC. It seems clear that learners must learn how to learn in a cMOOC.

In contrast to active participants, lurkers can potentially gain all the benefits of the course, but apparently contribute nothing in return. Discussing lurking in traditional online courses, Rovai (2000) describes lurkers as "learners who are bystanders to course discussions, lack commitment to the community, and receive benefits without giving anything back" (p. 291). This negative perception of lurkers was shared by some active participants who felt that being a lurker was incompatible with the concept of a cMOOC course, reliant as it is on participation and the activities of aggregation, relation, creation, and sharing identified by Kop (2011). However, cMOOCs must accommodate learners of all types to satisfy Downes' (2009) diversity and openness criteria. In practice, as long as there is a balance of these different types of learners, then lurkers can be accommodated, and the evidence from this study is that lurkers can learn effectively in connectivist environments: taking the knowledge they acquire to their own external networks.

In this study, the distinction between lurkers and passive participants reflects the observation that lurkers (most, but not all of whom self-identified as lurkers) were content with their participation in the cMOOC. In contrast, passive participants seemed frustrated with the course and their behavior indicates that they did not want the autonomy to choose where, when, how, and with whom to learn (Downes, 2009). Learner confidence was also a factor in this group, with some participants indicating that they felt they did not have anything useful to say. Others seemed to be lacking the critical literacies to learn effectively in a connectivist course.

The findings presented here are part of a larger study examining self-regulation of learning in cMOOCs. While the whole study contributes a substantial body of new empirical data about the learning experience afforded by cMOOCs, there are some limitations that must be acknowledged and considered. First, the sampling strategy used (recruitment via a call for participation included in the e-mail newsletter in Week 17 of the course) would not have reached participants who had already dropped out by this stage. Second, the authors noted that participants in this cMOOC were as interested in the cMOOC process, as in the Change11 content, and therefore it may be difficult to generalize the findings of this study to other courses. Careful design of future studies could avoid these limitations. Future studies should seek to compare the learning experience offered by different cMOOCs, target specific types of learners, and could attempt to follow learners across different cMOOCs to gain a better understanding of how critical literacies for learning in cMOOCs develop.

Understanding the nature of learners and their engagement is critical to the success of any online education provision, especially those where there is an expectation that the learner should self-motivate and self-direct their learning. Massive courses, by their very nature, bring in learners with a range of backgrounds, previous experience, and skill levels, and it is therefore incumbent on course organizers to design a learning experience that accommodates these diverse learner profiles. The three factors affecting engagement identified in this study (prior cMOOC experience, confidence, and motivation) provide an insight into how organizers of future cMOOCs might address this design challenge. Those participants who have not previously studied on connectivist courses can easily be identified. These participants may be given additional induction, or could be paired with a more experienced student who could act as a mentor. An approach like this would have helped Participant 13, who felt unable to find similar learners in the course. Those participants who lacked confidence could be paired with learners of similar experience to act as "buddies." Finally, learners could be encouraged to identify and articulate clear aims and goals for the course to increase motivation (Locke & Latham, 2002). Goals could also be used as a social object through which learners could find others with similar interests and aspirations (Milligan, Margaryan, & Littlejohn, 2012).

References

Anderson, T., & Dron, T. (2010). Three generations of distance education pedagogy. The International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning,12(3), 80-97. Retrieved from http://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/890/1663

Barnard, L., Lan, W. Y., To, Y. M., Paton, V. O., & Lai, S.-L. (2009). Measuring self-regulation in online and blended learning environments. The Internet and Higher Education, 12(1), 1-6. doi:10.1016/j.iheduc.2008.10.005

Bouchard, P. (2009). Pedagogy without a teacher: What are the limits? International Journal of Self-Directed Learning, 6(2), 13-22. Retrieved from http://www.sdlglobal.com/IJSDL/IJSDL6.2-2009.pdf

Castells, M. (1996). The rise of the networked society. Oxford, UK: Blackwell.

Daniel, J. (2012). Making sense of MOOCs: Musings in a maze of myth, paradox and possibility. Journal of Interactive Media In Education, 2012(3). Retrieved from http://jime.open.ac.uk/article/2012-18/html

Downes, S. (2008). Places to go: Connectivism & connective knowledge. Innovate: Journal of Online Education, 5(1). Retrieved from http://www.innovateonline.info/pdf/vol5_issue1/Places_to_Go-__Connectivism_&_Connective_Knowledge.pdf

Downes, S. (2009, February 24). Connectivist dynamics in communities [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://halfanhour.blogspot.co.uk/2009/02/connectivist-dynamics-in-communities.html

Fini, A. (2009). The technological dimension of a massive open online course: The case of the CCK08 course tools. The International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 10(5). Retrieved from http://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/643/1402

Garrison, D. R. (1997). Computer conferencing: The post-industrial age of distance education. Open Learning: The Journal of Open and Distance Learning, 12(2), 3-11. doi:10.1080/0268051970120202

Gijbels, D., Raemdonck, I., & Vervecken, D. (2010). Influencing work-related learning: The role of job characteristics and self-directed learning orientation in part-time vocational education. Vocations and Learning, 3(3), 239-255. doi:10.1007/s12186-010-9041-6

Guest, G., Bunce, A., & Johnson, L. (2006). How many interviews are enough? An experiment with data saturation and variability. Field Methods, 18(1), 59-82. doi:10.1177/1525822X05279903

Kanuka, H., & Anderson, T. (1999). Using constructivism in technology-mediated learning: Constructing order out of the chaos in the literature. Radical Pedagogy, 1(2). Retrieved from http://www.radicalpedagogy.org/Radical_Pedagogy/Using_Constructivism_in_TechnologyMediated_Learning__Constructing_Order_out_of_the_Chaos_in_the_Literature.html

Kop, R. (2011). The challenges to connectivist learning on open online networks: Learning experiences during a massive open online course. The International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning,12(3), 19-38. Retrieved from http://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/882/1689

Kop, R., & Fournier, H. (2010). New dimensions to self-directed learning in an open networked learning environment. International Journal of Self-Directed Learning, 7(2), 1-20. Retrieved from http://www.sdlglobal.com/IJSDL/IJSDL7.2-2010.pdf

Kop, R., Fournier, H., & Mak, S. F. J. (2011). A pedagogy of abundance or a pedagogy for human beings: Participant support on massive open online courses. The International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning,12(7), 74-93. Retrieved from http://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/1041/2025

Littlejohn, A., Milligan, C., & Margaryan, A. (2011). Collective learning in the workplace: Important knowledge sharing behaviours. International Journal of Advanced Corporate Learning, 4(4), 26-31. doi:10.3991%2Fijac.v4i4.1801

Locke, E. A., & Latham, G. P. (2002) Building a practically useful theory of goal setting and task motivation. American Psychologist, 57(9), 705-717. doi:10.1037/0003-066X.57.9.705

Mackness, J., Mak, S. F. J., & Williams, R. (2010). The ideals and reality of participating in a MOOC. In L. Dirckinck-Holmfeld, V. Hodgson, C. Jones, M. de Laat, D. McConnell, & T. Ryberg. (Eds.), Proceedings of the Seventh International Conference on Networked Learning (pp. 266-275). Lancaster, UK: University of Lancaster. Retrieved from http://www.lancaster.ac.uk/fss/organisations/netlc/past/nlc2010/abstracts/PDFs/Mackness.pdf

Maclellan, E., & Soden, R. (2006). Facilitating self-regulation in higher education through self-report. Learning Environments Research, 9(1), 95-110. doi:10.1007/s10984-005-9002-4

Milligan, C., Margaryan, A., & Littlejohn, A. (2012). Supporting goal formation, sharing and learning of knowledge workers. In A. Ravenscroft, S. Lindstaedt, C. Delgado Kloos, & D. Hernández-Leo (Eds.), 21st century learning for 21st century skills: Proceedings of the Seventh European Conference on Technology Enhanced Learning (EC-TEL 2012). Vol.  7563 Lecture Notes in Computer Science (pp. 519-524). Heidelberg, Germany: Springer. doi:10.1007/978-3-642-33263-0_53

Pintrich, P. R., Smith, D. A. F., García, T., & McKeachie, W. J. (1991). A manual for the use of the Motivated Strategies for Learning Questionnaire (MSLQ). Ann Arbor, MI: University of Michigan, National Center for Research to Improve Postsecondary Teaching and Learning. Available from ERIC database. (ED338122)

Rovai, A. P. (2000). Building and sustaining community in asynchronous learning networks. The Internet and Higher Education, 3(4), 285-297. doi:10.1016/S1096-7516(01)00037-9

Schraw, G., & Dennison, R. S. (1994). Assessing metacognitive awareness. Contemporary Educational Psychology, 19(4), 460-475. doi:10.1006/ceps.1994.1033

Sfard, A. (1998). On two metaphors for learning, and the dangers of choosing just one. Educational Researcher, 27(2), 4-13. doi:10.3102/0013189X027002004

Siemens, G. (2005). Connectivism: A learning theory for the digital age. International Journal of Instructional Technology and Distance Learning,2(1), 3-10. Retrieved from http://www.itdl.org/Journal/Jan_05/article01.htm

Siemens, G. (2012). MOOCs are really a platform [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.elearnspace.org/blog/2012/07/25/moocs-are-really-a-platform

Toering, T., Elferink-Gemser, M. T., Jonker, L., van Heuvelen, M. J. G., & Visscher, C. (2012). Measuring self-regulation in a learning context: Reliability and validity of the Self-Regulation of Learning Self-Report Scale (SRL-SRS). International Journal of Sport and Exercise Psychology, 10(1), 24-38. doi:10.1080/1612197X.2012.645132

Wilson, S., Liber, O., Beauvoir, P., Milligan, C., Johnson, M., & Sharples, P. (2007). Personal learning environments: Challenging the dominant design of educational systems. Journal of e-Learning and Knowledge Society, 3(2), 27-38. Retrieved from http://www.je-lks.org/ojs/index.php/Je-LKS_EN/
article/download/247/229

Acknowledgments

The authors would like to thank all those participants who gave their time for this study. They would also like to thank Lou McGill for conducting the interviews and Susan Houston for transcribing the audio of those interviews.


View the original article here

Evaluating the Strategic and Leadership Challenges of MOOCs

         Evaluating the Strategic and Leadership Challenges of MOOCs


Stephen J. Marshall

Centre for Academic Development
Victoria University of Wellington
Wellington NEW ZEALAND
stephen.marshall@vuw.ac.nz

Abstract

This paper presents an analysis of the strategic and leadership issues presented by the range of massive open online courses (MOOCs) and associated activities happening internationally. The analysis is framed by Porter's Five Forces and outlines a framework for use by institutional leaders and strategic planners exploring specific strategic and operational responses relevant to their particular institutional, social, national, and international contexts.

Keywords: massive open online course (MOOC), institutional strategy, Porter's Five Forces, open education

Introduction

Massive open online courses (MOOCs) have stimulated an international burst of activity examining the role technology plays in higher education (ACM Education Board / Council, 2013; Armstrong, 2012; Azevedo, 2012; Carr, 2012; Daniel, 2012; Feldstein, 2012; Kop, 2011; Siemens, 2012). The various magazine articles, publicity announcements, blog posts, and research papers, typified by the assertion that MOOCs "are the most important education technology in 200 years" (Regalado, 2012) are reminiscent of the millennial "global virtual university" hysteria (see, for example, Cunningham et al., 2000). While MOOCs are very unlikely to radically transform higher education, the attention being paid to the technology and the broader issues of the cost of and access to higher education provide a strategic opportunity for institutions and their leaders (Armstrong, 2012; Carr, 2012). Interestingly, there is some evidence that MOOCs are being explored most predominantly by large research institutions with no current online offerings, suggesting that it is being used as a strategic tool to explore alternative models of course delivery (Allen & Seaman, 2013).

MOOCs offer the opportunity to explore models of pedagogy with fresh eyes. The two main types of MOOCs focus on the knowledge to be learned (xMOOCs) and on the student as a member of a community of learners (connectivist or cMOOCs). Both are quite different starting points for education that contrast with the focus on the teacher or faculty member that typifies higher education. MOOCs are actual courses designed and supported by experts in the topic and intended to be taken by cohorts of students. In this, they differ from the myriad of MOOC-like educational media found on the Internet and from the resources commonly used as textbooks (Young, 2013).

MOOCs have features that are both attractive and threatening. The attraction comes from the promise of a large scale and very cheap course delivery arising from technological support of abundance (Batson, Paharia, & Kumar, 2008), as well as a sense that technology could deliver finally some of the potential it has promised for higher education over decades. The threat is the likelihood of competition and disruption. MOOCs threaten a degradation in the values of higher education, a proliferation of large scale experiences delivered by consortia or institutions internationally and without an awareness of the local students, cultures, values, or needs.

The open nature of MOOCs forces a consideration of the intellectual ownership models underpinning modern education (Ehlers, 2011; Stallman, 2002; United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization [UNESCO], 2012). Many institutions are seeking ways of diversifying their revenue streams. MOOCs imply different economic models for education, with MOOCs that use completely free licenses (such as OERu, the Open Educational Resource university) and those which have business models driven by monetization strategies other than up-front fees (e.g., Udacity and Coursera), although there is significant concern about the viability of the models proposed to date (Allen & Seaman, 2013; Young, 2012b).

MOOCs raise structural questions about education. The most prominent MOOCs exist within collaborations and while many of these are exclusive in their membership, commercial organizations such as Pearson Education, Instructure, and Blackboard are offering online environments capable of supporting institutional MOOC initiatives (Azevedo, 2012; Feldstein, 2012). These vendors are clearly positioning themselves in a new educational landscape, moving from a model of passive partnership and content provision to a more active participation in the educational process, including that of accreditation.

MOOCs commonly embody a sense of democratic and free access to education, a developmental agenda, and the philosophy that educational opportunities should not be limited to a privileged few. The implication is that students from diverse backgrounds can equally use these opportunities, something that glosses over the wide diversity in languages, educational backgrounds, social and cultural norms, and abilities that exist in the global population (Kop, 2011).

This focus on structures and longer-term strategies is distinct from discussions of other educational technologies cast in the mold of innovation. The narrative of disruptive innovation and the call for transformative change stimulated and sustained by new technologies is well established in many contexts including education (Christensen, Anthony, & Roth, 2004; Christensen, Horn, & Johnson, 2008). This paper is positioned within the context of a potential disruption, but rather than advocating a revolutionary disruption it is instead intended to focus on the role of strategy as a form of sensemaking (Weick, Sutcliffe, & Obstfield, 2005). The next section outlines a model of strategic analysis developed by Porter (1985, 2008) contextualizing it within the MOOC space and then applies it to two representative case studies as an illustration of its utility.

Applying Porter's Five Forces to the Strategic Question of MOOCs

Porter's (1985, 2008) Five Forces model supports a strategic analysis of the interactions between organizations, and the structures that frame their relative success and positions within that structure. The model frames strategic analysis of the structure of any domain using the eponymous five forces (Figure 1). Complementing these forces are other factors that need to be considered, such as industry growth, technology and innovation, and the relationship with other sectors including employers. Most particularly in the case of higher education, there is also the role that governments and accrediting bodies play.


Figure 1. Porter's Five Forces (Porter, 2008)

The Threat of Substitute Products or Services

Porter's "threat of substitute products or services" encapsulates the strategic challenge posed by MOOCs. Substitutes offer attractive price-performance outcomes and are easy to switch to from the established product. MOOCs are characterized as free (although they do have substantial opportunity costs if students engage seriously with the courses and use the collaboration and interaction facilities actively) and are very easy to enroll into and commence study. Substitution can be seen in terms of Christensen's model of new market and low-end disruptive innovation (Christensen et al., 2004). MOOCs are clearly a form of low-end disruption where virtually all of the added value and support of a formal education as well as the resulting high-quality qualification are discarded and the focus placed entirely on learning. Barriers to MOOC substitution include the utility ('performance' in Porter's terminology) of the resulting education, certificate, or qualification that almost certainly will be influenced by the common perception that free goods have no value.

Threat of New Entrants

"New entrants" to any industry, Porter's second force, bring new and different capabilities and are energized to compete with established organizations. Often they can draw upon success in other domains to access resources unavailable to the existing organizations. The lack of previous involvement in the new domain means that new entrants are not encumbered by investment (financially or psychologically) in old approaches and potentially they are better positioned to question established wisdom and assumptions that may no longer hold.

The likelihood of appearance of new entrants is a function of the barriers to entry. Higher education has traditionally used the processes of accreditation as a substantial entry barrier; however, its fundamental weakness is its dependence on societal acceptance that accredited institutions are substantially better than unaccredited ones. New entrants such as Pearson Education are demonstrating that they can provide a credible assurance of the achievement of students in non-accredited contexts such as MOOCs (Mary@Udacity, 2012).

An advantage of a strategy of charging for quality assurance and validation, rather than for education itself, is the ability to manage and control the outcomes. Latterly, for-profit education providers have been under close scrutiny for the quality of their programs and the value that they provide (Tierney & Hentschke, 2007). There is also the problem of plagiarism and fraud in online courses with the risk that this can taint the reputation of a provider and qualification (Council for Higher Education Accreditation & UNESCO, 2009; Wukman, 2012; Young, 2012a). There are clear models of the types of problems likely to be encountered apparent in the ways online game environments are manipulated by activities such as "gold farming" (Heeks, 2010), where commercial markets develop for outsourcing key tasks at the individual level, such as contributing to forums or completing assessment activities. These issues are avoided by placing the responsibility of becoming educated onto the student.

The strategic question for an existing provider is their response to these new entrants. Acceptance for transfer credit of the assurance statements of organizations like Pearson is already being implemented by some institutions (Mary@Udacity, 2012; Young, 2012c) as is the development of processes for validating work done through MOOCs outside the control of the institution (De Santis, 2012; Kolowich, 2013). The recognition of prior learning, long a challenging space for institutions (Harris, Breier, & Wihak, 2011), is likely now to become a more closely studied process, with the additional strategic risk that unjustified barriers erected as a form of educational protectionism are unlikely to be politically or socially sustainable.

Potentially significant barriers to new entrants are the incumbent institution's access to a substantial resource of expert pedagogical and subject knowledge in the form of the staff of institutions, along with legal advantages in copyright laws permitting the use of third party owned content by formally established educational institutions.

Institutions may find that their own staff are themselves new entrants, limiting the value of the first barrier. Non-tenured adjunct or contract staff working for incumbent institutions are a rich potential source of personnel and expertise for new entrants, and have no contractual loyalties to current employers. Tenured faculty have already been offering MOOCs of one type or another completely independently of any formal institution.

The legal and copyright issues raised by MOOCs are significant. The laws regarding educational use of third-party content vary dramatically from country to country. Individuals and institutions engaging in the creation and delivery of MOOCs need to be careful to ensure they are not subject unexpectedly to the laws of other countries, as for example might happen if their student body attracts a predominance of people from a single country. This goes beyond copyright to include issues of content (blasphemy and other laws), privacy of information, and protection of educational provision, as well as many others ("Ethiopia Bans Distance Education," 2010; Mangan, 2012).

The question of copyright and licenses is also relevant when considering the question of whether MOOC resources are available for use by other institutions in potentially competing courses. MOOCs, such as those offered by Coursera, are licensed only for use by individual students (Coursera, 2012). This raises the gray area of staff in other institutions referencing third-party MOOCs as additional readings (Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology, 2011). The choice of institutional license for MOOC resources will materially affect the strategic decisions being made with regard to investment in MOOC resource creation. Institutions producing MOOCs primarily as videos of lectures will have different perceptions of the value of those resources to institutions producing commercial quality distance education materials from scratch.

The Bargaining Power of Buyers

Porter's "bargaining power of buyers" force superficially describes students, but strategically it is a reflection of the influence and impact of a disparate group of key stakeholders.

Students depend on the system to deliver significant personal benefits, and make substantial personal investments in the system. Beyond fees, students all experience large opportunity costs by engaging in formal education as they forego earnings from full-time employment. Many students are heavy users of a variety of technologies in their personal and professional lives and expect it to play a role in a modern education (Kennedy et al., 2009). Technology can improve the responsiveness of large organizations, and introductory MOOCs potentially let students engage in study immediately. As alumni or graduates of the system, former students have an interest in sustaining and protecting the value of the qualifications they have achieved. Many institutions recognize this through the role that alumni play in governance.

The parents of students are significant stakeholders in the higher education system commonly through their financial support of students, but also in their influence over the choices students make when moving from the school system to higher education. Parental perceptions of the value of particular qualifications and aspirations for their child's success are likely to significantly influence decisions over the first qualification obtained.

Employers have become one of the most significant stakeholders in the higher education system. The role of employment in economic growth is so intimate that that employers inevitably have a substantial amount of political power and influence over the shape and priorities of the higher education system. Employers also have strong relationships through collaborative research and postgraduate study undertaken by their employees, with many universities benefiting from a regular exchange of staff and expertise with key industry participants.

Like employers, governments have become far more important stakeholders in higher education over the past century through substantial public investment in both institutions and the provision of financial subsidies for students that help mitigate or defer the personal costs of education. The price of that investment has been the growing dependence of institutions on the government for funding and the consequent power that has given governments to influence the shape of the system through quality and performance management.

The last major stakeholder is the academic faculty, particularly in the case of universities. Faculty work defines the university. The reputations and recognition of academics are included in the international ranking systems used to compare universities and many performance measures used by governments assess the success of faculty in their research and teaching work. Faculty members make the majority of decisions about the operational and pedagogical structure of teaching, either individually or collectively. Pragmatically, faculty decide whether or not students have demonstrated the qualities that are expected of graduates, and are substantially responsible for the perceived quality of graduates. This responsibility perhaps contributes to the concerns raised by some faculty regarding MOOCs in particular (Vardi, 2012) and online education more generally. Allen and Seaman (2013) report that academic leaders suggest that less than one third (30%) of U.S. faculty accept the value and legitimacy of online education, a number that has not substantially changed over the last decade.

MOOCs also have potential as a mechanism for development of faculty. Many of the existing participants in MOOCs state that they are validating or refreshing existing knowledge or skills and there is every reason to suggest that faculty would benefit from opportunities to do so themselves.

Institutional strategies and responses to MOOCs must reflect an understanding of the choices and influence of their stakeholders. The strategies of institutions secure in reputations of international significance such as Harvard University, Stanford University, and the Massachusetts Institute of Technology (MIT) can be quite different to those of institutions that do not have reputational capital to depend upon. It can be argued that the support of MOOCs by institutions with strong reputations is in part a strategy of disruption, shaping the perceptions of stakeholders in education (Armstrong, 2012; Hagel, Brown, & Davison, 2008).

The Bargaining Power of Suppliers

Powerful suppliers transfer costs to the enterprise or retain power and control over key aspects of the industry. Higher education is unusual in that a major supplier is the faculty who normally are the collegial owners of the institution and responsible for much of the leadership of the academy, as discussed above.

Powerful supplier groups also include the academic publishing consortia, typified by Pearson Education, technology companies such as Microsoft, Google, and Blackboard, and a vast array of companies providing specialist functions (many of which are owned or partnered by larger players). These vendors enable an institution to achieve the level of scalability and robustness needed to support MOOCs with potentially hundreds of thousands of students. It can be helpful to think about MOOCs as a platform (Siemens, 2012). By doing so, strategies can be developed regarding aspects such as course discovery and brokerage, the MOOC equivalent of Google for web pages. Other components of a platform likely to emerge are the brokering of course content licensed for MOOC use; professional skills and consulting in MOOC initiatives; and student recruitment, guidance, and counseling – just to name a few of the more obvious. Finally, MOOCs represent opportunities for institutions to develop experience in their strategies for use of commodity Internet platforms commonly referred to as the "cloud" without risking disruption to existing systems and courses.

Rivalry among Existing Competitors

Idealistically, in many countries the individual institutions comprising the publicly funded education sector should be working collaboratively and cooperatively to deliver the greatest value possible for the taxpayer. In reality, in many cases the individual institutions are run as separate entities and, as a result of management ideologies popular over the last few decades, forced to engage in a form of market competition intended to stimulate efficiency and entrepreneurship (Andrews, 2006; Barnett, 1992; Manning, 2013). Nationally and internationally, institutions compete for reputation, to attract the best and brightest students and faculty, for research grants, and on various ranking and performance tables maintained by governments and media companies. Despite this competitive disposition, MOOC initiatives to date have been characterized by extensive international collaborations.

A Framework for an Institution's Strategic Engagement with MOOCs

This analysis of strategic structure of the MOOC domains has identified a number of questions of institutional strategy and direction that can be used to systematically develop a strategic response to the MOOC phenomenon, and more broadly the use of online models of course and program delivery. These questions provide a starting point for a consideration of the particular situation of a given institution. The specific circumstances of a given institution will naturally steer the analysis towards some questions more urgently than others. The examples that follow illustrate hypothetical examples based on real-world institutional situations in order to demonstrate how different elements of this framework are of greater or lesser significance in different contexts. This quick analysis would clearly only form the starting point for a much more extensive conversation with key internal and external stakeholders questioning the status quo, implicit and explicit assumptions, and identifying additional options for the institution.

The two cases used to provide a context to the framework were chosen from a set of organizational changes cases (Marshall, 2012a). The responses are derived from those cases and reflect an external analysis of each organization's capability, the opportunities and threats they face from their current positioning. It should be noted that they were chosen deliberately to contrast different analyses, and not as definitive examples. Table 1 summarizes the strategic questions arising from the Five Forces analysis above, and the contrasting analysis of the two institutions.

Table 1. Strategic framework for MOOCs outlined and illustrated with two institutional example

Private Training Establishment PTE-A1. Threat of Substitute Products or Servicesa) What are the fundamental qualities of the institution's educational offerings that differentiate the institution?Degrees well regarded but of similar quality to other New Zealand universities.Vocational qualification in a single industry delivered entirely online by experienced staff, only specialist provider of this type in the country.b) How is the value of the institutional educational offerings communicated to each of the key stakeholder groups and differentiated from substitutes such as MOOCs?Traditionally accredited qualifications.Emphasis made on the quality of the teaching and support provided to the students, very strong focus on pastoral support.c) Can MOOCs be substituted for existing activities in ways that strengthen the institution?Potential to provide preparation activities for students, option for some courses over the third "summer" trimester, option as source for remedial or additional support for students in some courses.Initial course for students on how to learn as an online student could be reconfigured into a MOOC, may act as marketing tool and means of filtering potential students to select those motivated and able to learn well online.d) Are MOOCs already, or potentially, a risk for substitution for key institutional offerings?Minor risk for technical subjects taught at post-graduate level to students wanting to maintain or develop their skills but uninterested in qualifications.No risk as qualification is mandatory for employment in industry and legal and ethical issues mean that this is never likely to change.e) What is the institution's strategy for recognition of student learning undertaken in different contexts?Very limited credit transfer systems.f) Should MOOC completion contribute towards the achievement of institutional qualifications?State of program development and lack of experience in RPL make this unlikely.Inconsistent with quality assurance requirements.g) What legal and economic factors affect the viability of MOOCs as substitutes and what risks exist for political influence changing those factors?Government very interested in ways by which sub-degree teaching can be delivered at no cost to the taxpayer, conscious of risks to market for international students.Legal requirement that students be qualified, supervised and registered to work in industry, political interest in minimizing costs but very unlikely to remove qualifications as requirement for large proportions of the workforce.a) How is the institution managing its strategic relationships with other organizations that potentially could offer MOOCs as alternatives to the institutions offerings?Not currently in any collaborations or similar relationships.Not currently in any collaborations or similar relationships.b) Who are the other institutions influencing the institution's own offerings and how is that influence understood and managed?Main influences are the other New Zealand universities through shared academic approval processes, and the funding agency the Tertiary Education Commission (TEC), which controls and approves funding levels for all qualifications.Limited in New Zealand by vocation-specific legal requirements, accreditation and quality assurance requirements, and by the TEC for the number of students and qualifications that can be offered.c) What strategies are in place to mitigate any risk that MOOCs are able to influence the size of the student cohorts for particular offerings?None, presumption that MOOCs are not influencing student choices.None, existing offerings over-subscribed.d) What strategies are in place to mitigate any risk that distribution channels might be influenced by new entrants with conflicting agendas, such as existing partners in related industries (e.g., publishing and technology)?All systems developed in-house and key intellectual property is all owned entirely by the institution.e) What is the institution's strategy for developing and sustaining a competitive advantage in expertise in areas important to key educational offerings?Targeting resources for employment of staff to specific subjects on the basis of their strategic importance, strategic renewal process underway focusing on learning and teaching, with particular emphasis on the role of technology in supporting face-to-face education.Significant investment in sustaining and further developing expertise in technical and educational aspects of online learning, actively participating in benchmarking activities and collaborative research nationally and internationally.f) Are there ways by which the institution can act as a new entrant for parts of its business?Challenging given the constraints of the local environment and lack of existing resources and experience.Currently investing in multiple initiatives in other countries where it is acting as a new entrant.g) What is the institutional strategy for the ownership and management of intellectual property?Staff own the copyright in their teaching materials, very limited support for staff although work in progress to expand copyright and license support.All resources and systems owned by the institution and managed formally.a) How is the institution managing the perceptions and expectations of each key stakeholder group regarding MOOCs, technology innovation in general, and most importantly the cost and access to higher education?Currently developing a technology strategy for learning and teaching, stakeholder engagement plan not yet developed, cost focus primarily political as fees determined by Government policy.Clear strategy of positioning institution as high quality online provider with excellent support and engagement systems in place to help students succeed. Very strong relationships with employer groups in the industry and active voice in collective bodies relevant to sector.b) What is the institution's strategy for developing the skills of its existing faculty and other staff, and how does the MOOC strategy enhance or support this?Traditional model of faculty development dominated by optional support. Strategy for digital technology includes strong skills development goals.Prior to teaching students, all staff required to complete a formal online training program in online teaching and learning, this program includes technical, pedagogical, and institutional aspects.4. Bargaining Power of Suppliersa) How does the institution engage with faculty regarding the strategic direction for its offerings and the role that MOOCs might play formally and informally in the experience of teachers and students?Developing a technology strategy for learning and teaching that includes faculty engagement component.Very clear strategy for technology use communicated to all staff regularly and incorporated into training materials.b) How are relationships with key partners being used to advance both the strategic and operational interests of the institution?Very dependent on key technology partners for nature and types of technologies used in education. Innovation strategy for learning and teaching in development.Partners used for commodity services only, key systems and resources completely owned in-house.5. Rivalry among Existing Competitorsa) What is the institution's strategy regarding the use of resources from its own offerings by other institutions, including those in direct competition?Complete ownership of resources.b) How might new or existing institutional relationships be strengthened through engagement with MOOCs?Potential for national collaborations in the development and provision of induction and preparation MOOCs for all universities, particularly for students from Maori and Pacific Island groups and those coming directly from schools in low socio-economic areas.Limited engagement in MOOCs with other institutions in vocational training, particularly those in other institutions, could enhance leadership position nationally and stimulate further improvements and knowledge, as well as potentially new types of business opportunity leveraging the investment in proprietary systems and potential for expert consultancies.Case Example 1

University NZ-C is a medium-sized New Zealand university with a traditional focus on face-to-face education and an emphasis on research and postgraduate education. The University is financially secure but faces significant challenges resulting from the current Government's decision to change the funding model from one of growth to one where numbers are capped. The University has been recently engaging with the implications of technology in its learning and teaching activities but benchmarking suggests that it is well behind international comparators and has struggled to change (Marshall, 2012c).

The responses to the strategic framework (Table 1) are consistent with the lack of any strategic position for technology generally, and thus the inability to clearly articulate a response to the concept of the MOOC. In common with many institutions (Allen & Seaman, 2013) University NZ-C is undecided about MOOCs. The framework responses suggest a degree of strategic and operational risk from MOOCs arising from uncoordinated activities undertaken by individual groups of faculty independently of the institution.

One possible strategy University NZ-C has for avoiding strategic paralysis is in the area of induction and preparation programs. The New Zealand Government has forbidden universities from charging fees for such sub-degree courses; however, the institution still has the materials and designs, which could easily be redeployed in MOOC form. An extension of this would be further work targeting Maori and Pacific Island students while still in school; using the MOOCs to prepare students for the idea of university study well before they complete school education.

Case Example 2

PTE-A is a commercial, for-profit, private training establishment (PTE) providing vocational training to approximately 1500 students engaged in full- and part-time study (Marshall, 2012b). PTE-A's students are predominantly mature and are based throughout New Zealand, usually in either part-time or full-time employment in a single very tightly defined and regulated industry.

PTE-A has deliberately been engaging in a strategy of renewal and innovation for much of the last decade with a strong leadership focus on the use of technology. As apparent in the answers in Table 1, the institution has invested heavily in the development of systems and resources for online education and has used their experience of distance education to ensure that students experience a supportive and successful online education. Consequently, the institution has been able to achieve high levels of student success in its online courses and in recent years this has culminated in the complete transition to online delivery.

As a successful for-profit online provider PTE-A is hypothetically at risk from wide adoption of MOOCs and the strategic analysis reflects the potential threat. The regulatory context of its industry provides a significant barrier to new entrants and the reality is that this is very unlikely to change. PTE-A's ownership of key resources and systems gives it a strong position with regard to substitution and suppliers, and it has clear strategies in place to manage buyers and competitors within the same industry. Beyond this however, and consistent with the benchmarking of the institution, PTE-A has a strong culture of continuous improvement and innovation that is supporting its own activities as a new entrant into international markets for its courses. Each of these new markets would need to be analyzed using this framework, as different assumptions, constraints and opportunities will be present. In some of these new markets PTE-A may find MOOCs represent either a challenge or an opportunity.

Discussion and Conclusion

The analysis presented in this paper is framed in the context of the MOOC phenomenon and the current economic challenges facing all institutions. It should be apparent, however, that this type of analysis and the strategic awareness it supports must be dynamic. Pursuit of strategies for online education by institutions like Harvard, Stanford, and MIT has already changed the environment they were originally enacted in. Visionary strategists recognize this and adapt the execution of the strategy in real time. Both of the cases presented here are at best starting points. A real strategy would also need to address a number of specific challenges in addition to those identified already, potentially creating niches for differentiation between competitors (ACM Education Board / Council, 2013):

Knowledge and information presented over multiple learning platforms;Students need to be more responsible for their own learning, able to manage their own time, and maintain their own motivation to complete courses;Students need reliable and inexpensive access to the Internet for extended periods of time in an environment conducive to learning;Online learning, being designed for a large audience, often lacks any responsiveness to the individual student's cultural and professional experience, particularly students from underrepresented groups;Reflection and critical analysis are challenging to support without individual teacher attention on the work of the student;Online learning environments struggle to identify students disengaging from courses or failing to cope with material being taught. Many institutions will be in similar positions to University NZ-C, dimly aware of MOOCs at best, unclear as to the implications, lacking knowledge about key stakeholder needs and expectations, and inexperienced in their own use of technology. In contrast, PTE-A represents an example of the type of institution that might itself be a new entrant, a disruptor of existing assumptions and business models. Education is one of very few industries in which such insider disruption is possible and even necessary (Christensen et al., 2008).

Finally, the model and analysis presented in this paper, while framed and stimulated by MOOCs, clearly applies to a range of challenges arising from online education. Practitioners in the field have watched technology influence and change higher education in many ways over the past decades but have yet to see transformation in the experience of students and teachers. The approach presented here should not be seen as further encouragement for perpetual analysis. The MOOC strategies of institutions such as Harvard, Stanford, and MIT are potentially shaping the perceptions of many stakeholders in higher education (Hagel et al., 2008). By giving away course materials and access to basic e-learning systems these institutional MOOCs are establishing a minimum threshold of quality that must be substantially exceeded by other organizations (particularly non-accredited ones) wanting to charge for their materials. The key idea behind such a shaping strategy is that by articulating it, and stimulating engagement with and responses to the key elements of the strategy, industry participants are motivated to adopt disruptive strategies collaboratively. Shaping strategies act to discourage the natural tendency of threatened organizations to retrench and adopt conservative and self-protective strategies that collectively can cause an industry to stagnate.

Educational institutions have been described as prone to strategic paralysis (Christensen et al., 2008) through their attempts to completely analyze situations prior to acting upon them. The pace of technological change and the intensity of the political and economic pressures upon institutions mean that a strategic response to MOOCs, and online education generally, should involve at least a proportion of action early. Fullan and Scott (2009) argue that institutions should adopt a "ready, fire, aim" (p. 26) attitude, which is to say that strategy should be informed by and evolve rapidly in response to experience, rather than specified completely prior to execution.

In conclusion, institutions are encouraged to analyze the five forces that structure their place within higher education, to think strategically, but above all, to act, to innovate, and to use that experience to stimulate and sustain change.

References

ACM Education Board / Council. (2013). Online learning in computing [White paper]. New York, NY: Association for Computing Machinery. Retrieved from http://www.acm.org/education/online_learning_white_paper.pdf

Allen, I. E., & Seaman, J. (2013). Changing course: Ten years of tracking online education in the United States. Babson Park, MA: Babson Survey Research Group and Quahog Research Group. Retrieved from http://www.onlinelearningsurvey.com/reports/changingcourse.pdf

Andrews, J. G. (2006). How can we resist corporatization? Academe Online, 92(3), 16-19. Available from JSTOR database. (40252920)

Armstrong, L. (2012). Coursera and MITx: Sustaining or disruptive? [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.changinghighereducation.com/2012/08/coursera-.html

Azevedo, A. (2012, November 1). Course-management companies challenge MOOC providers [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/course-management-comp...lenge-mooc-providers/40734

Barnett, R. (1992). Improving higher education: Total quality care. Buckingham, UK: The Society for Research into Higher Education and Open University Press.

Batson, T., Paharia, N., & Kumar, M. (2008). A harvest too large? A framework for educational abundance. In T. Iiyoshi & M. S. V. Kumar (Eds.), Opening up education: The collective advancement of education through open technology, open content and open knowledge (pp. 89-103). Cambridge, MA, USA: MIT Press.

Carr, N. (2012, September 27). The crisis in higher education. MIT Technology Review. Retrieved from http://www.technologyreview.com/featuredstory/429376/the-crisis-in-higher-education/

Christensen, C. M., Anthony, S. D., & Roth, E. A. (2004). Seeing what's next: Using the theories of innovation to predict industry change. Boston, MA: Harvard Business School Press.

Christensen, C. M., Horn, M. B., & Johnson, C. W. (2008). Disrupting class: How disruptive innovation will change the way the world learns. New York, NY: McGraw-Hill.

Council for Higher Education Accreditation, & United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. (2009). Toward effective practice: Discouraging degree mills in higher education. Washington, DC and Paris, France: Authors. Retrieved from http://www.cicic.ca/docs/CHEA-UNESCO-degree_mills_statement.en.pdf

Coursera. (2012). Terms of service and privacy policy. Retrieved from https://www.coursera.org/about/terms

Cunningham, S., Ryan, Y., Stedman, L., Tapsall, S., Bagdon, K., Flew, T., & Coaldrake, P. (2000). The business of borderless education. Canberra, Australia: Department of Education, Training and Youth Affairs. Retrieved March 29, 2012, from http://www.dest.gov.au/archive/highered/eippubs/eip00_3/bbe.pdf (archived at http://web.archive.org/web/20120329115850/http://www.dest.gov.au/archive/highered/eippubs/eip00_3/bbe.pdf)

Daniel, J. (2012). Making sense of MOOCs: Musings in a maze of myth, paradox and possibility. Journal of Interactive Media in Education, 2012(3). Retrieved from http://jime.open.ac.uk/article/2012-18/html

De Santis, N. (2012, October 29). Antioch U. will offer MOOC's for credit through Coursera [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/blogs/ticker/antioch-u-will-offer-moocs-for-credit-through-coursera/51252

Ehlers, U.-D. (2011). Extending the territory: From open educational resources to open educational practices. Journal of Open, Flexible and Distance Learning, 15(2), 1-10. http://journals.akoaotearoa.ac.nz/index.php/JOFDL/article/viewFile/64/46

Ethiopia bans distance education, cracks down on private universities. (2010). Voice of America. Retrieved from http://www.voanews.com/content/ethiopia-bans-distance-education-cracks-down-on-private-universities-101882818/159961.html

Feldstein, M. (2012, November 4). Everybody wants to MOOC the world [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.mfeldstein.com/everybody-wants-to-mooc-the-world/

Fullan, M., & Scott, G. (2009). Turnaround leadership for higher education. San Francisco, CA: Jossey-Bass.

Hagel, J., Brown, J. S., & Davison, L. (2008). Shaping strategy in a world of constant disruption. Harvard Business Review, 86(10), 80-89.

Harris, J., Breier, M., & Wihak, C. (2011). Researching the recognition of prior learning: International perspectives. Leicester, UK: National Institute of Adult Continuing Education.

Heeks, R. (2010). Understanding "gold farming" and real-money trading as the intersection of real and virtual economies. Journal of Virtual Worlds Research, 2(4). Retrieved from http://journals.tdl.org/jvwr/index.php/jvwr/article/download/868/633

Kennedy, G. E., Dalgarno, B., Bennett, S., Gray, K., Waycott, J., Judd, T., ... & Chang, R. (2009). Educating the net generation: A handbook of findings for practice and policy. Melbourne, Australia: The University of Melbourne. Retrieved from http://www.netgen.unimelb.edu.au/downloads/handbook/NetGenHandbookAll.pdf

Kolowich, S. (2013, February 7). American Council on Education recommends 5 MOOCs for credit. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/article/American-Council-on-Education/137155/

Kop, R. (2011). The challenges to connectivist learning on open online networks: Learning experiences during a massive open online course. The International Review of Research in Open and Distance Learning, 12(3), 19-38. Retrieved from http://www.irrodl.org/index.php/irrodl/article/view/882/1689

Mangan, K. (2012, October 18). Minnesota gives Coursera the boot, citing a decades-old law [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/blogs/wiredcampus/minnesota-gives-coursera-the-boot-citing-a-decades-old-law/40542

Manning, K. (2013). Organizational theory in higher education. New York, NY: Routledge.

Marshall, S. (2012a). E-learning and higher education: Understanding and supporting organisational change in New Zealand: Research report. Wellington, New Zealand: Ako Aotearoa National Centre for Tertiary Teaching Excellence. Retrieved from http://www.akoaotearoa.ac.nz/download/ng/file/group-3991/e-learning-and-higher-education-understanding-and-supporting-organisational-change.pdf

Marshall, S. (2012b). E-learning and higher education: Understanding and supporting organisational change in New Zealand. Case study: Private training establishment. Wellington, New Zealand: Ako Aotearoa National Centre for Tertiary Teaching Excellence. Retrieved from http://www.akoaotearoa.ac.nz/download/ng/file/group-3991/case-study-private-training-establishment-pte.pdf

Marshall, S. (2012c). E-learning and higher education: Understanding and supporting organisational change in New Zealand. Case study: University. Wellington, New Zealand: Ako Aotearoa National Centre for Tertiary Teaching Excellence. Retrieved from http://www.akoaotearoa.ac.nz/download/ng/file/group-3991/case-study-university.pdf

Mary@Udacity. (2012, June 1). Udacity in partnership with Pearson Vue announces testing centers [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://blog.udacity.com/2012/06/udacity-in-partnership-with-pearson-vue.html

Porter, M. E. (1985). Competitive advantage: Creating and sustaining superior performance. New York, NY: Free Press.

Porter, M. E. (2008). The five competitive forces that shape strategy. Harvard Business Review, 86(1), 78-93.

Regalado, A. (2012). The most important education technology in 200 years. MIT Technology Review. Retrieved from http://www.technologyreview.com/news/506351/the-most-important-education-technology-in-200-years/

Royal Melbourne Institute of Technology. (2011). Can I use MIT Open Courseware? Retrieved April 24, 2012, from http://www.rmit.edu.au/browse;ID=bh2uj6bha59hz (archived at http://web.archive.org/web/20120424113828/http://www.rmit.edu.au/browse;ID=bh2uj6bha59hz)

Siemens, G. (2012). MOOCs are really a platform [Web log post]. Retrieved from http://www.elearnspace.org/blog/2012/07/25/moocs-are-really-a-platform/

Stallman, R. (2002). Free software, free society: Selected essays of Richard M. Stallman. Boston, MA: GNU Press. Retrieved from http://www.gnu.org/philosophy/fsfs/rms-essays.pdf

Tierney, W. G., & Hentschke, G. C. (2007). New players, different game: Understanding the rise of for-profit colleges and universities. Baltimore, MD: The Johns Hopkins University Press.

United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization. (2012). UNESCO World Congress releases 2012 Paris OER Declaration. Retrieved from http://www.unesco.org/new/en/communication-and-information/resources/news-and-in-focus-articles/all-news/news/unesco_world_
oer_congress_releases_2012_paris_oer_declaration/

Vardi, M. Y. (2012). Will MOOCs destroy academia? Communications of the ACM, 55(11), 5. doi:10.1145/2366316.2366317

Weick, K. E., Sutcliffe, K. M., & Obstfield, D. (2005). Organizing and the process of sensemaking. Organization Science, 16(4), 409-421. doi:10.1287/orsc.1050.0133

Wukman, A. (2012, August 22). Coursera battered with accusations of plagiarism and high drop-out rates. OnlineColleges.Net. Retrieved from http://www.onlinecolleges.net/2012/08/22/coursera-battered- with-accusations-of-plagiarism-and-high-drop-out-rates/

Young, J. R. (2012a, August 16). Dozens of plagiarism incidents are reported in Coursera's free online courses. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/article/Dozens-of-Plagiarism-Incidents/133697/

Young, J. R. (2012b, July 19). Inside the Coursera contract: How an upstart company might profit from free courses. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/article/How-an-Upstart-Company-Might/133065/

Young, J. R. (2012c, November 13). American Council on Education may recommend some Coursera offerings for college credit. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/article/American-Council-on-Education/135750/

Young, J. R. (2013, January 27). The object formerly known as the textbook. The Chronicle of Higher Education. Retrieved from http://www.chronicle.com/article/Dont-Call-Them-Textbooks/136835/


View the original article here